Why are many chinese sauces so dark?

Why are many chinese sauces so dark? - Stack of various Asian tea jars

I've noticed that many sauces used in chinese cooking (hoisin, oyster, bean etc.) are relatively dark, and often black in color. What's the reason these sauces are so dark? Does it have something to do with the fermentation?



Best Answer

You're close. In actual fact, however, most of the commercial soy sauces and other Chinese sauces you buy are not fermented at all; they're acid-hydrolyzed.

Fermented soy sauce (or other soy-based sauces) are actually translucent and fairly light in colour. But fermentation takes months, so manufacturers hydrolyze instead. The process is completely chemical, and involves boiling the beans in a strong acid and then neutralizing with a strong base (normally, hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide).

This process makes a much stronger, glutamate-heavy sauce than natural fermentation. It also produces a much darker colour. That's why so many of the sauces you see are dark.

Some of the sauces aren't actually hydrolyzed or fermented but will contain artificial colour, if you look at the ingredients. I guess the manufacturers figure that consumers are so used to the dark colour that they would be suspicious if it wasn't there.


Here is a picture of naturally brewed soy sauce:

Fermented Soy Sauce

Compare to the commercial hydrolyzed kind:

Hydrolyzed Soy Sauce

Some brands, like Kikkoman, claim to be naturally-brewed, but the colour suggests otherwise; either they do something to speed up the fermentation process or they're adding colouring.

Note: As requested, I've updated the original image to one I found of a bowl of what certainly appears to be the hydrolyzed kind, in order to give an "apples to apples" comparison. However, it's hard to find a picture of a bowl of soy sauce that tells you which brand it is, other than the Kikkoman, whose origin is questionable.

For the sake of completeness, there is also one other reason why soy sauce might be very dark (other than actual "dark soy sauce" which contains molasses), which is that the sauce might actually be from black soybeans. Those are not common, however, and unless a sauce specifically says that it is from black soybeans, it probably is not.




Pictures about "Why are many chinese sauces so dark?"

Why are many chinese sauces so dark? - From below of many red rice paper lanterns with golden hieroglyphs hanging on street during celebration of Chinese Spring Festival
Why are many chinese sauces so dark? - High angle of brown beech mushrooms native to Asian countries placed on beige background
Why are many chinese sauces so dark? - High angle of cluster of brown beech type of gourmet oyster mushroom growing in Asia placed on beige background



Is there a difference between light and dark soy sauce?

What is the difference between Light and Dark Soy Sauce? To put it simply, light soy sauce is used for seasoning and dark soy sauce is used for adding colour to dishes. Light soy sauce is golden brown in colour and rich in taste to add flavour during marinating and seasoning stage.

Is premium soy sauce light or dark?

Lee Kum Kee Premium Light Soy Sauce Light Soy Sauce is great for adding savoury and umami flavour to the dish while Dark Soy Sauce is ideal for adding a rich and natural deep colour to enhance the appearance of the dish. They complement each other and in Chinese cuisine, both Soy Sauces are commonly used together.

Is Kikkoman soy sauce dark or light?

For example, Kikkoman's regular Traditionally Brewed Soy Sauce is a dark soy sauce. In Chinese cooking, it's the opposite: light soy sauce is more common. Bottles will indicate light\u2014sometimes labeled "thin" or "superior"\u2014or dark.

Can you make dark soy sauce light?

There's no great way to convert dark soy sauce into light soy sauce. I would follow the same instructions for diluting the dark soy sauce listed above where you add extra salt and a tiny bit of water to thin it and make up for the saltiness. Alternatively, you could forgo soy sauce and use a light soy sauce substitute.



Difference between DARK soy sauce \u0026 LIGHT soy sauce - Authentic homemade Chinese food!




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Tianwang Xiao, Angela Roma, Laker, Laker