Substituting maltose for barley malt syrup in bagels
Can I substitute Chinese-style maltose (麥芽糖 if you want to search it up) for barley malt syrup in bagels?
From what I understand, the flavour won't be exactly the same, but I'm not sure whether the latter affects the hydration, and how they should be substituted. Can they be swapped directly 1 to 1 (by weight), or must the quantity be adjusted?
Also, if you are not sure what I mean by maltose and barley malt syrup, here are some Amazon links:
Maltose
Barley malt syrup
Best Answer
I would expect that substitution to work fine, in a 1:1 swap.
Both Brown Rice Syrup (what you're calling Maltose) and Barley Malt have a high amount of maltose-the-sugar, plus an assortment of other sugars. Both are pretty close to pure glucose in their actual sugar content, while at the same time tasting less sweet because of their composition and some of their minority content.
Barley Malt is going to be a bit "darker", with more "roasted" flavors than commercially manufacturer brown rice syrup (although artisan traditionally made brown rice syrup would be very similar). So it won't add quite as much flavor to the bagel dough as barley malt will. However, speaking from experience, you can make bagels using white sugar instead of any kind of malt, and they still come out fine.
There's one exception here, and that's pumpernickel bagels. These dark brown bagels depend heavily on the roasted flavors of dark barley malt (in either syrup or powder form). I wouldn't try substituting with those.
Pictures about "Substituting maltose for barley malt syrup in bagels"
What can I use instead of malt syrup for bagels?
11 Substitutes for Barley Malt Syrup in Bagels- Honey. Honey is a good substitute for barley malt syrup because it's nearly as sweet and has a similar amount of sugar, which helps the yeast in the dough rise. ...
- Corn syrup. ...
- Brown rice syrup. ...
- Light honey. ...
- Molasses. ...
- Black treacle. ...
- Agave nectar. ...
- Brown sugar.
Is maltose the same as barley malt syrup?
Maltose (m\xe0i y\xe1 t\xe1ng, \u9ea6\u82bd\u7cd6) is a natural sweetener produced from fermented grains like barley and rice. Also sometimes called malt syrup or malt sugar, maltose has the consistency of neither syrup nor sugar! It's much more viscous than a syrup\u2013\u2013more solid than liquid, really\u2013\u2013and is also less sweet than sugar or honey.What can you use instead of barley malt syrup?
However, when it comes to last-minute needs, you can pick a substitute for barley malt syrup from the list below.- Honey. One of the reasons why people look for a malt extract substitute is because they want a gluten-free alternative, like honey. ...
- Molasses. ...
- Brown rice syrup. ...
- Maple syrup. ...
- Maltose. ...
- Korean rice syrup. ...
- Sugar.
Is barley malt syrup necessary for bagels?
So what makes a bagel a bagel? As previously mentioned, it has to contain barley malt syrup. Sugar, honey, and molasses are simply no substitutes for this complex, not-particularly-sweet, tar-like substance. A bagel also has to be boiled before it is baked.Bagels made with malted barley syrup | NY-style boiled
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Ion Ceban @ionelceban, Lubomir Vladikov, ramona ignat, Akshay Kumar