Popped lid in pressure canning

Popped lid in pressure canning - Free stock photo of adult, band, celebration

One of the lids on a quart jar of green beans "popped" after sitting on the kitchen counter for two days. It was one of a batch of a dozen jars canned in that session. The others are fine after a week. The jars were processed in a pressure canner at 14# for 25 minutes. The jar was placed in the fridge. Should the contents be discarded? Also, ideas on what could have caused this? I'm thinking a defective lid?



Best Answer

Yes, the contents should be discarded. Putting it in the refrigerator after the seal fails is too late.

Time and temperature kill pathogens, so it's not so much the pressure as the through-and-through temperature of the food that matters... Something insulating in the beans could harbor bacteria. I've seen a fly grow an interesting little blob of an ecosystem.

A defective lid or something on the rim causing physical air infiltration are more likely to fail by the time it reaches ambient temperature. A delayed failure isn't impossible, but there should be evidence of a defect on the seal.




Pictures about "Popped lid in pressure canning"

Popped lid in pressure canning - Man in Black and Brown Plaid Coat and Orange Knit Cap Standing Beside Man in Black
Popped lid in pressure canning - Man in Black and White Jacket Holding Black Smartphone
Popped lid in pressure canning - A Man in Orange Knit Cap Beside a Man in Green Knit Cap



Are canning lids supposed to pop?

Two-Piece Canning Lid BasicsIf it pops up and down, it is not sealed, and you must refrigerate or reprocess the contents immediately. You can also check the seal by removing the ring and grabbing the lid with your thumb and middle finger.

What happens if you over process when canning?

"If jars are overfilled, the contents may siphon or boil out during processing," Piper explains. "Any food residue remaining on the jar rim, such as grease, juice, seeds, or pulp can prevent the formation of an airtight seal." Which is why you should also wipe off the jar rim after filling!



Are Canning Lids Supposed to Pop?




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Alena Darmel, Anna Pou, Anna Pou, Anna Pou