How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere?

How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere? - Crop people clinking glasses over table

When I try to separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab, the moment the lid separates from the can, the lid flings food everywhere. It's not always a lot, but it goes far because the lid has so much spring-tension.

I'd keep the last bit of the lid on the can, but sometimes I need the lid off to get everything out or to fully clean the can. (I don't want any remaining food in the can afterwards. My house pets will try to steal the can, and wild animals will try to steal the can from my recycling bin.

What methods can be used to avoid the mess and keep the kitchen clean?

Canned food with pull tabs
(Image from self.com)



Best Answer

For most of the removal, leverage rather than brute force will give more control, so you don't accidentally pull the last bit off.

At the end while pulling gently on the ring, rock the lid from side to side, so you're only trying to open one side of the remaining seam. It's much less likely to flick that way. While my right hand does that, my left hold the can in such a way that it would probably be in the way of anything flying, but it rarely needs to.

Another approach is to open the lid most of the way, remove most of the contents, then push the lid inwards to finish breaking it off (or in/out until the metal fatigues and it breaks easily). This works well for things like beans or custard, that come out easily with a pour/scrape.




Pictures about "How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere?"

How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere? - High angle of male pouring carbonated drink from tin can to smiling black friend sitting with red cup
How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere? - Burger on Top of Newspaper
How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere? - Black and Silver Can Showing Back Content



Quick Answer about "How can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere?"

  • Push the lid back down.
  • Pull the lid back up.
  • (Try to push it inwards after several back and forth)
  • Repeat until it wears down and break off by itself.


  • How do you open a can with a pull tab?

    Put your index finger through the ring and place your thumb on top of the lid. While pulling on the ring, press down on the top of the lid with your thumb creating a rolling motion as the lid pulls away from the can. To break the last portion of the seal, gently rock the lid from side to side until it breaks free.

    How do you open a can without a ring pull?

    THE REASON is that "ring-pulls" or Easy-Open (EO) ends are slightly more expensive, so they tend to be mainly used for the more expensive premium quality products. However, market research has shown that many consumers would be prepared to pay a little more for food in an easy-open can because of the added convenience.

    Why do cans have ring pulls?

    In 1959, Ermal Fraze devised a can-opening method that would come to dominate the canned drink market. His invention was the "pull-tab". This eliminated the need for a separate opener tool by attaching an aluminum pull-ring lever with a rivet to a pre-scored wedge-shaped tab section of the can top.



    How To Open A Can Of Food If The Pull Tab Came Off




    More answers regarding how can I separate the lid from a can that has a pull-tab/ring without flinging food everywhere?

    Answer 2

    This answer is not ideal, as it avoids the use of the pull-tab altogether:

    Use a regular can opener instead. No flinging of food involved!

    Answer 3

    The lid isn't flinging the food around. That happens because the can is moving.

    The simple solution is hold the can firmly in place on a table, worktop, etc, with one hand, while you pull on the ring with the other. If the can doesn't move, the contents won't go anywhere.

    Answer 4

    One useful trick I've found is to judge the point at which the lid is close to detaching from the can, and then rotate it 90 degrees. Keep pulling it in the same direction as before to detach it, but now:

    1. The edge of the lid now rests against the edge of the can, like a lever, and you've got much more control over it, meaning you can apply a more gentle force and carefully lever it off
    2. The force you're applying doesn't bend the lid, so when it detaches it won't spring back and fling food everywhere.

    Answer 5

    • Remove the lid slowly.
    • Hold a paper towel around the opening at the last moment when the lid detaches.
    • Minimise the quantity of food on the underside of the lid by storing the can upright, and perhaps tapping the can on a surface (keeping it upright) a few times before opening to dislodge the remainder.

    Answer 6

    The crucial thing is, don't put your finger through the loop and pull straight up. It's essential to put your thumb on the lid, then use your middle finger in the loop and lever the lid over your thumb.

    Answer 7

    On the same approach as what @Chris H is suggesting about pushing the lid inwards.

    Once I opened the lid as far as possible, what I tend to do is:

    • Push the lid back down.
    • Pull the lid back up.
    • (Try to push it inwards after several back and forth)
    • Repeat until it wears down and break off by itself.

    You don't need to do it fast. Do it at your own pace and it will eventually wear down.

    The advantage of this approach is that you don't need to apply strength nor anything, so you avoid having food flying around, or accidentally cutting your hand with the sharp edge of the lid.

    Answer 8

    I put the handle of a wooden spoon through the loop, and lever it thus, while holding the can down firmly on a surface.

    A top view picture of a can. The loop has been lifted up perpendicularly to the unopened lid. A wooden stick has been inserted through the loop. The edge of the stick has a dent, which allows it to sit firmly against the edge of the can, when it's used as a lever to open the lid.

    Although the lever is inefficient, it gets you nearly all the way. Once there, you can floor the end of the handle on the surface, and, while still holding the can down, a few back-and-forth bends on the remaining hinge does the rest.

    Answer 9

    Are you opening some super industrial strength cans or something?

    1. Set the can on a table
    2. Lift the tab up so the front pokes down into the food and breaks the vacuum seal.
    3. Pull the tab backwards, not upwards, so the lid 'peels' off the top of the food inside.

    Answer 10

    Open the can inside a clear plastic bag.

    Answer 11

    When I try to do this, I use a combination of things I have seen here in the other answers:

    1. Start by lifting the tab so that the corner of the lid separates inward while giving increased attention to the pressure inside the lid

      • a paper towel around and over the top might be used to prevent the overpressure discharge of slightly pressurized cans
      • This point might not always be possible, as the ring might be weakly attached or the lid might be attached too much

    1. Rest the back of your palm or your thumb as a leverage point against the part of the lid opposite to the ring
      • what I mean by that is to pull your middle finger or pointer finger through the ring from the top
      • rest the back of your palm against the back of the lid (the place directly opposite to the ring)
      • if the can is too small or your hands are weak, place your thumb at the middle or back part of the lid instead
      • Open the first half/two-thirds of the lid by pressing the middle finger against the back of your palm and gently lifting your palm from the back of the lid
      • If you used your thumb instead, use the thumb as the fulcrum point

    1. Open the last bit by gently placing the thumb on top of the remaining attached part opposite the ring and use it as leverage and to control the flicker of the part as it separates from the rest of the can
      • you can also open the remaining part by SWAYING your palm left and right with the thumb as a leverage
      • The thumb now ensures that the lid does not "spring" away while it separates from the can and does not fling food to undesirable locations

    I am feeding our dog and cat daily with wet canned food in combination with the food we cooked/prepared ourselves and this is the way I developed to prevent flickering the food off of the lid under spring tension.

    Answer 12

    A pair of hand can be seen opening the lid of a can with a can opener. Notice that it isn't a standard can opener that simply cuts off the lid, but a side cutting can opener, which cuts the lid off the can from the side, instead of from the top

    Just use one of these (non-standard) bad boys. (A smooth edge can opener)

    Answer 13

    Firmly hold the can down against a fixed surface so that it cannot move when it separates from the lid, preventing spills.

    To capture material flicked from the lid, do this at the bottom of a sink rather than a table or countertop.

    Or drape a cloth over your hand to capture the splatter.

    Answer 14

    On the odd occasions when the ringpull has failed, I resort to the humble can opener. Never let me down yet ! But as far as your problem is concerned, you can resort to the same for the last part of the circumference. That gets the whole top off with no drama.

    Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

    Images: Rachel Claire, William Fortunato, alleksana, Tima Miroshnichenko