Carbonation diffuser versus shaking
Currently I use the "shake" method of carbonation to carbonate beverages. You pressurize the bottle with CO2 at about 35 PSI then shake it vigorously for about 30 seconds and it is fully carbonated.
Recently I have discovered that beer makers use a "diffuser" which is a cylinder with microscopic holes in it to inject CO2 into their liquid (beer) and carbonate it. Will a diffuser work as well as shaking and fully saturate the liquid?
One of my concerns is that some beer manuals describe carbonation as taking hours or days. I want to carbonate a bottle in like 5 seconds rather than the 30 seconds it is currently taking me.
Typically I am carbonating one to two liters of water/syrup at a time.
Concerning Soda Stream: the problem with something like Soda Stream is two fold. First of all, their CO2 canisters are small and expensive. The other is that the momentary injection type system they use (which I could duplicate if I wanted) can only get the pressure up to about 20 PSI which is way below saturation. With my system I can easily get fully saturated 35-40 PSI, which is what a soda can or fountain produces.
Best Answer
The solubility of Carbon Dioxide (CO?) in water (or beer, soda, soft-drinks) is governed by the pressure of CO?, temperature of water, and the amount of CO? already dissolved in the liquid.
Obviously the surface area of contact is important in helping the gas dissolve. This is where these sintered steel stones help break up the gas into micro bubbles. I regularly use a one of these diffusers to dissolve O? into an aqueous solution. While it's better than not having a diffuser, it's no magic solution. I'd expect you'd still have to shake the vessel. At no time can I adjust the rate of gas so it never rises to the top of the vessel - that is: it does never completely dissolve.
So to answer your question: Yes it helps, but no you will still probably need to shake the bottle. Also the diffusers themselves need to be carefully cleaned and sanitised (by boiling) after use.
So what can be done here? Temperature is a primary factor, and probably the only one that is easily controlled. If you can cool your beverage down to near-zero, the gas will dissolve more readily.
And
"Effect of temperature on the rate of CO2 dissolution"
Note how much faster the CO? dissolves in colder water. Obviously higher pressure helps too.
Pictures about "Carbonation diffuser versus shaking"
Can you carbonate water by shaking it?
No. Shaking will create a lot of small bubbles which will act as nucleation points to release the dissolved gas when the container is opened and the pressure released.Are you supposed to shake SodaStream?
Tilt the carbonating bottle at an angle and pour the flavor into your sparkling water. Close the bottle with the fizz-preserving cap and shake gently to mix. Enjoy your bubbles!Is it better to carbonate cold or warm water?
Carbon Dioxide (and gases in general) dissolve more easily in cold liquids. This means that it's easier to carbonate (inject with Carbon Dioxide) your soda using cold water than warm. As your liquid heats up the gas falls out of solution creating the bubbles in your soda.Does carbonating water make it colder?
Both cold carbonated water and cold still water lower the body temperature when swallowed. However, we found that the sensory stimulation caused by carbonated water in the mouth produces additional effects that decrease body temperature.Beer Carbonation Test for Craft Brewery, Zahm Nagel!!
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Ketut Subiyanto, cottonbro, Ketut Subiyanto, Huỳnh Đạt