Spring onion (green onion/scallion) in coq au vin?
I recently ran into an Australian recipe for coq au vin that called for "spring onions", which (in Australia) refers unambiguously to what the French call cébette:
Oddly, the recipe calls for 800g of them (spring onions are sold by bunch, not weight), says you should "trim green ends, leaving about 4cm of stem attached; trim roots" (not a whole lot of spring onion left if you follow this!), and then continues with "cook onion, stirring, until browned all over", which doesn't seem like the kind of thing you'd usually do to spring onions.
So is spring onion for coq au vin an actual thing in France? Or did a clueless editor somewhere along the way confuse shallot/échalote in the original (below) with spring onions, which are also known as "eschalots" in Australia?
Best Answer
Australian and keen Coq au Vin maker here; I am in Sydney so my response may be subject to regional variations; Australia is a big place.
There is yet another possibility. These
Coq au Vin requires onions twice; at the start, chopped, and later on, where the recipe I use (Mastering the Art of French Cooking) calls for small onions browned and braised in stock. In Australia it isn't easy to get onions of the right size for the latter dish - even the smallish onions sold as pickling onions are IMHO too big. The bulbs of the spring onions behind the link are the right size, about an inch in diameter.
As you can see from the other products on the page, yes, we have no standard naming convention. I'm British by birth, so I'll always refer to French Shallots as Shallots, and the OP's cebette as Spring Onions.
As an aside, http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/wordofmouth/2011/mar/24/how-perfect-coq-au-vin is well worth consulting. In fact the whole series is well worth consulting.
Pictures about "Spring onion (green onion/scallion) in coq au vin?"
Can I use spring onions instead of scallions?
Though there are slight differences between scallions, green onions and spring onions, they can be used interchangeably in recipes. They're often added to stews, stir-fries and salads.Is scallion and spring onion the same?
Scallions and green onions are literally the same thing. The only difference is how they're chosen to be labeled at the store. Spring onions, on the other hand, are a different thing. The bulb of a spring onion is much larger, compared to the small, not-so-bulbous scallion.Can you substitute green onions for scallions?
Scallions are also great uncooked and have a fresh allium flavor. They're largely interchangeable with green onions, which are actually immature bulb onions, says \u201cThe New Food Lover's Companion\u201d by Sharon Tyler Herbst and Ron Herbst. True scallions are milder than green onions.Can I use spring onions instead of shallots?
A great shallot substitute is to use green onions, or scallions in place of shallots. Another names for scallions is spring onions. Scallions have a naturally milder flavor than onions, so they are excellent as a replacement for shallots in salads and uncooked recipes.[Eng cc] Scallion, Green onion, Spring onion, Leek, Big green onion EXPLAINED | 蔥
More answers regarding spring onion (green onion/scallion) in coq au vin?
Answer 2
The intent could be to indeed use just the "not whole lot left" - the white part and 4cm of the stem, and discard (or use otherwise) the rest. Using just this part is also common in building the aromatics set for wok dishes - just that the green parts tend to be used as garnish later.
Specifying by weight is actually more precise here, since bunch sizes can vary, and there are varieties with a straight white part (a true scallion) and others having a bulbous part almost like a white onion (a true spring onion)...
Since the white part is by far the heaviest part, it would be easiest to shop for them by laying bunches on the produce scale until you get approximately two pounds together (prices for spring onions could be very variable across the world - in some European countries they are rather cheap, eg usually around 30-40 cents a bunch in Germany).
Answer 3
According to "How to cook everything" by Mark Bitman, it is "two medium onions chopped". Normal onions. They are added to the mushrooms while making the sauce. With this, I will say it is not a thing in French cuisine.
But I think your Australian recipe really want spring onion because of the technique described. It is really what I'm used to and doesn't apply to shallot nor onion.
Also, here in Québec, Canada, we call "spring onion" «échalote» and "shallot" «échalote française». Happy to not be the only one confused !
From the book, I also got the actual name of the recipe : Chicken in Red Wine Sauce.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Angela Roma, Vanessa Loring, Vanessa Loring, Engin Akyurt