Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references

Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references - Person Holding Green Ceramic Mug

I remember reading that some scientific researchers in Japan (I think) discovered that when it came to stirring liquids, moving a spoon back and forth was more efficient at mixing the liquids than if you moved the spoon in circles. I've experienced this to be true. Nevertheless, I would like to find the evidence of this, either in original source material or articles about it and I'm coming up with nothing on Google.

Does anybody remember this or have links to the research?



Best Answer

Well, this does not surprise me. If you move the spoon in circles, you create a shearing action between the faster moving spoon and the slower liquid. This is where you create a force that makes the two different liquids mix. If you move it back and forth, you still have the shearing action between the spoon and the liquid and it is the same as before, as it only depends on the size of the spoon and speed and length of movement, but also the action of the liquids knocking into each other. This is a stronger force than by going in circles as the molecules crash into each other, instead of side-by-side.

Of course, the difference in technique depends a lot on how much force the liquids need to mix in the first place. So, you should be able to easily verify this if you use water and oil and try to mix them by stirring in circles and going back and forth. The difference should be noticeable, while the difference for water and ink should not be detectable.

I don't know the Japanese research, but Harold McGees 'On Food and Cooking' confirms this in the section about whipped cream, how this force allows the fat globules to destabilize (and finally end up as whipped cream).




Pictures about "Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references"

Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references - Person Pouring Water Into a Coffee Filter
Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references - Person Holding Brown Ceramic Mug With Black Liquid and a Spoon
Optimal stirring technique: I read that stirring liquids in a straight line is better than in a circle, but I can't find any references - Photo of a Man in a Green Long Sleeve Shirt Mixing Liquid in a Measuring Cup





How to Mix a Drink - are you doing it wrong?




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Anna Pou, Karolina Grabowska, Karolina Grabowska, Annushka Ahuja