How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong?

How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong? - Flat-lay Photography of Variety of Vegetables

The standard advice, for both steak and fish is to cook them to an internal temperature of 160 degrees to kill any bacterial contamination. Is this overly simplistic advice that's mostly incorrect? Please hear me out:

In the case of fish, the pathogen people worry about is listeria and it's generally introduced by incorrect handling at the fish processing plant. For beef, we're talking salmonella and friends. Same situation though: "The muscles of healthy animals contain less or nil microorganisms though, meat can be contaminated during slaughtering and transportation " (see article). To me it seems that the bacterial contamination is therefore on the surface of the meat or fish.

When we put meat or fish into an oven or on the grill, the outer surface is cooked first, eventually heating up the inside of the meat. By the time the inside of the fish or meat reaches medium-rare or medium, the outside has long surpassed the temperature needed to kill any pathogens on the surface of the meat. If we know that the pathogens are introduced on the surface of the meat and are killed off when we heat the surface, why is the standard advice to cook the fish and meat to an internal temperature that's unnecessary and potentially makes the protein taste worse than it needs to be? Do the bacteria grow into the meat or fish in some way? I imagine that they way they grow is along the surface of the meat, so unless you're cooking hamburger, there's no reason in the world to overcook it. Am i missing something?

I've been thinking about this question of food safety for a while, and I was hoping someone knows enough about this topic to illuminate the situation.



Best Answer

I'm pretty sure the 160 degree temperature is for mechanically tenderized beef. In that case, the manufacturers use machines with needles to "poke" the meat so any pathogens on the surface can get transferred to the inside. With non-mechanically tenderized beef the safe internal temperature is lower.




Pictures about "How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong?"

How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong? - Green Vegetables In A Bowl
How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong? - Food Meal In  White Ceramic Bowl
How does bacterial contamination grow on food, and is the standard advice to cook your food to a high internal temperature wrong? - Onions, Garlic and Tomatoes Close-up Photo



How does bacteria grow on cooked food?

After a food is cooked and its temperature drops below 130 degrees, these spores germinate and begin to grow, multiply and produce toxins. One such spore-forming bacterium is Clostridium botulinum, which can grow in the oxygen-poor depths of a stockpot, and whose neurotoxin causes botulism.

Does bacteria grow on high risk foods?

High-risk foods, also called potentially hazardous foods, are foods that have ideal conditions for bacterial growth, and are therefore more likely to harbour dangerous bacteria and other disease-causing pathogens like viruses and parasites.

What happens to bacteria when food is cooked to its appropriate temperature?

Above 74\xb0C (or 165\xb0F), bacteria die, although spores and toxins may survive. Food that is being cooked or reheated should hit 74\xb0C (or 165\xb0F). You can hold hot food for service at 60\xb0C (or 140\xb0F).

Why must food be cooked to the correct temperature?

In raw foods, such as meat, fruit and vegetables, high levels of bacteria may be present due to contamination with soil or due to the preparation process. It is important that food is cooked thoroughly to a core temperature of at least 75\xbaC for at least two minutes to kill the bacteria.



Food Safety: Meet Bacteria




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Engin Akyurt, Daria Shevtsova, Horizon Content, Engin Akyurt