Is this soup, stew, or something else?

Is this soup, stew, or something else? - Man Wearing Black Apron Near Two Silver Metal Cooking Pot

I ate some East Asian dish recently and it looked something like this:

Hot Pot

[image source: http://www.thetabletopcook.com/images/tabletop-cooking-homemade-taiwanese-hot-pot.jpg]

I had never eaten anything that looks like it. I was confused, is it a soup with some solids added to it?

I want to know about nomenclature for this type of food and how they would be classified (not according to taste, but according to how they look/are arranged/are mixed).



Best Answer

It's a hot pot or steamboat as we call it in Malaysia. It's a clear soup made from stock. Raw ingredients are gradually added to it as it simmers. Soup and the cooked ingredients are fished out when they are done (each time when the pot boils). At the end, you are left with a rich, delicious soup that has flavours of all the ingredients intermingled and it is usually eaten with noodles.

Going by this, it would be classified as a soup or broth. It wouldn't be a stew as flour has not been used to thicken it.




Pictures about "Is this soup, stew, or something else?"

Is this soup, stew, or something else? - Man in Pink Crew Neck T-shirt
Is this soup, stew, or something else? - Man in Pink Crew Neck T-shirt
Is this soup, stew, or something else? - Diverse Group of People in Swimwear Looking for Something in Sandy Beach



Quick Answer about "Is this soup, stew, or something else?"

Soup can either be completely liquified, or it can include other elements (such as meat, fish or vegetables) that are fully submerged in broth, water or stock. Stew, however, is much heartier and thicker than soup.

At what point does a soup become a stew?

The main difference between soup and stews is the amount of liquid they contain. While soups contain enough cooking liquid to fill a bowl and allow its ingredients to float, stews contain just a bit cooking liquid to simmer the other ingredients.

What are the 4 other types of soup?

There are four main categories of soup: Thin, Thick, Cold and National.

Is Chile a soup or stew?

Though many people think of chili as its own category, it is technically just a type of stew, with origins in Tex-Mex cuisine. Chili isn't a soup mostly because it usually is more solid than it is liquid, with most chili recipes containing majority meat and/or vegetables that are simmered in a tomato sauce.

What are the 5 types of soup?

B. Thick Soups:
  • Puree: Puree soups are thick soups made by cooking and then pureeing vegetables or ingredients used in the soup. ...
  • Velout\xe9: A velout\xe9 is a thick soup, which is thickened with a blond roux, passed and finished with a liaison. ...
  • Cream: A cream soup is a passed thick soup. ...
  • Bisque: ...
  • Chowder:




\




More answers regarding is this soup, stew, or something else?

Answer 2

It's definitely a kind of soup or stew.

The image you picked specifically calls it a "hot pot".

http://www.thetabletopcook.com/images/tabletop-cooking-homemade-taiwanese-hot-pot.jpg

Hot Pots are classified as "stews" according to Wikipedia:

Hot pot (also known as steamboat in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, the Philippines and Brunei), refers to several East Asian varieties of stew, consisting of a simmering metal pot of stock at the center of the dining table. While the hot pot is kept simmering, ingredients are placed into the pot and are cooked at the table. Typical hot pot dishes include thinly sliced meat, leaf vegetables, mushrooms, wontons, egg dumplings, and seafood. Vegetables, fish and meat should be fresh. The cooked food is usually eaten with a dipping sauce. In many areas, hot pot meals are often eaten in the winter during supper time.

But I'd argue that they're more soup-like. They remind me a lot of a Mexican dish called "caldo de pollo/res", which is literally "chicken/beef broth".

From the definition of "stew":

Stews are similar to soups, and in some cases there may not be a clear distinction between the two. Generally, stews have less liquid than soups, are much thicker and require longer cooking over low heat. While soups are almost always served in a bowl, stews may be thick enough to be served on a plate with the gravy as a sauce over the solid ingredients.

Your image, and this one of caldo are very broth-y, which is why I think they're more like soup.

Caldo de Res

Answer 3

That is certainly a stew. I might further refer to that as a hot-pot if the ingredients were raw before added to the broth, particularly if it's cooked at the table.

Answer 4

That particular dish looks to me like Chinese hot pot, or a similar Asian hot pot (not to be confused with Lancashire hotpot, which is a kind of stew!).

The main feature of the dish is that you have a pot at your table with a burner underneath, and a number of raw ingredients which you add to the broth and pull out at your own convenience. These may include meat, root vegetables, leaf vegetables, noodles, eggs, seafood or fish.

I would argue that it's not a soup or a stew, because the components are fished out and eaten, and are the main part of the dish. You can optionally drink the broth when you are finished, and I guess you could call that part of the dish a soup (though I would say "broth" to connote the thin-ness), but the dish as a whole is just hot pot. You don't call it a stew when you boil ravioli, right? ;)

From Wikipedia:

Hot pot (also known as steamboat in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, the Philippines and Brunei), refers to several East Asian varieties of stew, consisting of a simmering metal pot of stock at the center of the dining table. While the hot pot is kept simmering, ingredients are placed into the pot and are cooked at the table. Typical hot pot dishes include thinly sliced meat, leaf vegetables, mushrooms, wontons, egg dumplings, and seafood. Vegetables, fish and meat should be fresh. The cooked food is usually eaten with a dipping sauce. In many areas, hot pot meals are often eaten in the winter during supper time.

Answer 5

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Timur Saglambilek, MART PRODUCTION, MART PRODUCTION, Ron Lach