How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware?

How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware? - Black and White Polka Dot Textile

How safe are iron and carbonsteel pans? Or can they be misused making them unsafe?

For instance, have food safety authorities already reviewed this? Is there a regulation or at least a published opinion from an official body? For example, something like this opinion the European Food Safety Authority has published on PTFE (like Teflon) and PTFE coated cooking ware.


In order to have iron pans and carbonsteel to be non-stick one creates a patina layer on them by seasoning it. That is, burning fats and oils in thin layers onto the surface of the pan, creating a black layer of pyrolised and oxydized hydrocarbons (and probably all sorts of chemicals). (And it also changes the metal structure of the surface)

pan with patina

How is it with this 'burnt' patina layer? Is that layer safe? Or is it typically safe, but can it be unsafe when not properly done?


The specific section in the EFSA article is "3.1.3.1. Migration from food contact materials, including non-stick coatings used on cookware"

The article is EFSA Panel on Contaminants in the Food Chain (CONTAM), et al. "Risk to human health related to the presence of perfluorooctane sulfonic acid and perfluorooctanoic acid in food." EFSA journal 16.12 (2018): e05194.






Pictures about "How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware?"

How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware? - Rusted Grey Padlock in Selective-focus Photography
How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware? - Exterior of contemporary wooden orange door and black cast iron gates to house
How safe is the patina layer on seasoned cast iron or carbon steel cookingware? - Metal lock on deck of boat



Is cast iron coating toxic?

Enamel-covered Cast Iron: Although Enamel-covered cast iron ware can be very expensive (Le Creuset, for example), it does not react with any food; therefore, it is totally non-toxic. It lasts many years and holds the heat well because it is so heavy.

Is pre seasoned cast iron cookware safe?

"In general, cast-iron cookware is safe and effective in the kitchen. It may be a great addition for those who are deficient in iron, as it has great potential for some of the iron to make its way into the food." She also notes that well-seasoned cast-iron pans are durable and can last for a long period of time.

What is the safest cookware for your health?

Best and Safest Cookware
  • Cast iron. While iron can leach into food, it's generally accepted as being safe. ...
  • Enamel-coated cast iron. Made of cast iron with a glass coating, the cookware heats like iron cookware but doesn't leach iron into food. ...
  • Stainless steel. ...
  • Glass. ...
  • Lead-Free Ceramic. ...
  • Copper.


Is carbon steel wok toxic?

But people often wonder about the safety of woks, non-stick pans, and other cookware. They often have a factory coating or non-stick coating, which can contain toxic chemicals. So, is a carbon steel wok safe? Yes, it is non-toxic so it's perfect for all kinds of cooking.



Cast Iron Vs Carbon Steel Vs Stainless Steel | Which Skillet Should You Buy?




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Tim Mossholder, Artem Beliaikin, Erik Mclean, Athena