Are there alternatives to okra as a thickening agent?
I had a go at making a gumbo last week, and it went really well. The only problem was that the okra proved to be fairly difficult to source (after several supermarkets and groceries, we managed to find a tin of the stuff in a specialist food shop).
Given that the okra is used as a thickening agent, via the mucilage that sweats out when cooking, is there any other vegetable based alternative that would help keep the flavour of the gumbo, and thicken up the soup?
I'm specifically trying to avoid cornstarch or cornflour, since that would likely affect the flavour considerably. I was thinking potato, which is also starch, but that would also probably affect the flavour a fair bit. I realise that any alternative would have some effect, but would like to minimise it.
Best Answer
Filé powder (ground dried sassafras leaves) would be style-appropriate.
Fresh okra is only just now coming into season in the American south. I'm in Tennessee and most supermarkets carry fresh okra for most of the year (though it often looks quite sickly), and frozen year-round.
If it's something you enjoy, you might look into growing your own, as it tastes excellent when it's fresh picked and handled appropriately.
Pictures about "Are there alternatives to okra as a thickening agent?"
Quick Answer about "Are there alternatives to okra as a thickening agent?"
Good thickening alternatives for okra include file powder, arrowroot, cornstarch, roux, and nopales.What can I substitute okra with?
To replace okra as a thickening agent in gumbo, soups, and stews, the best options are gumbo fil\xe9, roux, xanthan gum, corn starch, or nopales. Vegetables such as zucchini, green beans, and eggplant have a similar flavor and can replace okra as a side dish.What can I replace okra with in jambalaya?
What Can You Substitute for Okra?Do you need okra in gumbo?
A lot of people don't like okra or think they don't like okra. But it's a very important part of this gumbo, adding both flavor and acting as a thickener. Note: If you want to try a Seafood Gumbo without okra, try this Seafood Gumbo.What does okra taste similar to?
What Does It Taste Like? Okra has a mild, almost grassy flavor that is uniquely okra. While it's sometimes compared to the taste of eggplant or green beans, its texture gets more attention. Okra is crunchy when cooked quickly but becomes almost mouthwateringly tender when slow-cooked.What Are The Best Okra Substitutes?
More answers regarding are there alternatives to okra as a thickening agent?
Answer 2
Strictly speaking most gumbo recipes I am familiar with rely on the use of a roux as the primary thickening agent. Sure the okra contributes somewhat but in my experience using a darkened roux is what is called for.
Please keep in mind that the more you cook the roux the less thickening power it has so you need to use a little more.
Answer 3
I use minute tapioca ~ 1 tablespoon/quart of mix. Taste variation is minimal.
Answer 4
Xanthan gum has almost no flavour profile and a much smaller amount is needed to thicken than cornflour so might be worth considering. You can usually find it in the 'free from' section of larger supermarkets and grocery stores.
Answer 5
I ordered ground okra on line and tried it in a gumbo along with a light roux. I am very pleased with the results. Be very careful with dried ground okra as it only takes a little bit to go a long way. Try 1/4 tsp. per pint of fluid. Advise to experiment with a measuring cup of water 'til you get the consistency you like before adding to gumbo. When added directly to gumbo it takes a few minutes to begin to thicken. It does add a bit of a savory flavor to the gumbo almost the same as fresh fried okra.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Phuc Pham, Quang Nguyen Vinh, Pavel Danilyuk, Pavel Danilyuk