Why is my white bread with poolish dough very loose?
I previously asked a question about the White Bread with Poolish from Ken Forkish's book Flour Water Salt Yeast. My first attempt with a flour that had 10% protein resulted in dough that hold its shape, but the poolish didn't expand enough so flavor wasn't as great. So, I decided to use flour from my bakery and asked for baguette flour. I don't know anything about its protein content, but I imagine its bread flour. When using this flour, my dough gets good elasticity when I am folding it and a poolish that nearly triples in size, but after the bulk fermentation it's no longer as elastic which makes it impossible to shape. I know bread flour absorbs more water so if that is the case then shouldn't it be firmer and more elastic. I measured everything by weight. Should I go for a poolish with bread flour and try the rest with all purpose? But, it doesn't make sense why would it be less elastic. I imagine the only explanation would be that the "bread flour" has less than 10% of protein. Any thoughts? The hydration level of the bread is 75%. The bread tastes good in the end, it's just a hard crust. Anyone else done this recipe?
Update: the bread rose perfectly and the crust was thin, but I still have no idea how to shape it. It looks good for a non-shaped loaf.
Best Answer
The protein content of your flour may have something to do with it, but it may also be the fermentation of your poolish. The more fermentation a dough goes through, the more the yeast turn starches into acid. Acids can denature gluten and gluten-forming proteins, leading to a less elastic dough. When you're adding your poolish to the rest of the ingredients, you're also adding its acid. The poolish is always going to be goopy and loose, so switching to bread flour for the poolish may not have the effect you desire.
Unfortunately, I'm more or less in the same boat. Like you mentioned, a higher protein content may help. That said (if I remember correctly), Forkish recommends AP flour for all of his recipes. Perhaps a shorter poolish ferment, or shorter bulk ferment.
Pictures about "Why is my white bread with poolish dough very loose?"
Why is my bread dough so floppy?
Do not let your bread loaves rise to more than double the size of your lump of dough. If they over rise, they're bound to make a floppy, spill over the pan loaf.How do you fix loose bread dough?
To add extra water to a dough, do so in the mixing bowl when kneading. Consider the amount of water already used and add an extra 2% at a time, until the right consistency is reached. Adding extra water to a dough that's already formed can be a pain, especially when kneading by hand!What percentage of dough should be poolish?
HOW MUCH POOLISH TO USE IN THE DOUGH? Depending on the recipe, you can use a percentage of Poolish from 20% to 40% of the total flour's weight (from 1kg of flour to make bread, you can use 200gr to 400gr for Poolish the rest for the final dough).What is the consistency of poolish?
Poolish has a loose consistency and is typically made with equal parts water and flour with a small percentage of commercial yeast. Biga, which is more like a dough than a batter, has a lower hydration than poolish and sponge, which is mostly used for enriched doughs, contains milk, eggs, butter, and/or sugar.White Bread with Poolish
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Cats Coming, Pierre-Antoine Caisso, Marina Leonova, Thirdman