When should one knead dough in a food processor vs. a stand mixer?
Every now and then I come across a bread recipe that calls for a food processor to mix and knead the dough. I know it's very quick, but is it actually the right tool for the job? This recipe calls for a food processor, and every time I make it I'm worried I'm going to destroy the machine: the thing shakes and wobbles alarmingly, so that I have to hold it steady the entire time, and I'm always worried about burning out the motor. And this is a sturdy, 14 C (3.3 L) Cuisinart machine.
So: is it actually preferable to knead dough in a food processor? It just doesn't seem like it's built for that job.
(I'm assuming here that there's an answer beyond "individual preference," but maybe I'm wrong.)
Best Answer
According to Stella Parks (in these recipes 1 2), food processors are ideal for breads requiring "intensive gluten development": bagels, whole wheat loaves, or other breads made with high-protein flour. Her main concern is stiff or glutinous doughs burning out the motor or gearbox of a stand mixer. While there are a wide variety of stand mixers on the market, common models use plastic or nylon gears which can break if the machine faces too much resistance. Food processors, on the other hand, have powerful induction motors that are less likely to fail in this manner.
Another advantage of a food processor is speed: dough is fully needed in under 2 minutes, while stand mixers can take up to 10. Again this is a factor of the differing motor and transmission.
Speaking from personal experience, wet doughs tend to gum up my food processor blade, slowing the machine down, and making cleaning difficult. Some recipes attempt to avoid this problem my adding the liquids in two steps: first a relatively dry dough is kneaded to develop gluten, then the remaining liquid is streamed in. In a stand mixer, on the other hand, you can almost always add all the ingredients and flick the switch. For these reasons, I stick with a stand mixer unless I am dealing with a truly tough dough, like one of the two recipes linked above.
Pictures about "When should one knead dough in a food processor vs. a stand mixer?"
Quick Answer about "When should one knead dough in a food processor vs. a stand mixer?"
Both types of appliances offer powerful help with bread. If speed is your thing, using a food processor for kneading dough edges out the stand mixer ever so slightly because of its lightning-quick speed. If you're making pizza dough for dinner, the food processor is a great go-to.Is food processor good for kneading dough?
You could use a stand mixer (for detailed information on how to knead dough in a stand mixer, see this article) but by far the fastest, easiest way to knead almost any dough is in the food processor. The rapid action of a food processor's blade can turn dough elastic in just minutes with almost no effort.Is it better to knead dough by hand or with a mixer?
So while hand kneading can be a gratifying process, we recommend using a stand mixer with the dough hook attachment for this task. A dough hook is the best tool you can use to knead dough. It does everything your hands would do, but more quickly.Can I use a food processor instead of a dough hook?
You can use a stand mixer, but by far the quickest, most effortless way to work almost any dough is using the food processor. The fast movement of the blades in a food processor can make your dough elastic within minutes almost effortlessly.Can you use a food processor instead of a stand mixer?
With a variety of functions, both mixers and food processors allow you to whip, mix, chop, mince and more when using different attachments and accessories. So, no matter where you stand in the food processor vs stand mixer debate, they can both be invaluable kitchen tools.How to knead dough in Food Processor
More answers regarding when should one knead dough in a food processor vs. a stand mixer?
Answer 2
It's not preferable to use a food processor over a mixer with a hook, it's just a bit faster - food processors spin very rapidly and put a lot of energy into the dough quickly. A dough hook does the same thing, it just takes more time. A lot of it is personal preference, in my case I don't like either and prefer to knead by hand as I enjoy the process, if I am going to use a machine it's going to be my mixer with a hook as I can see the dough develop. With a food processor I'm constantly concerned it will self-destruct and take me with it in an explosion of polycarbonate shards, plus it turn dough rubbery very quickly if you leave it on too long.
So, use your hands, mixer or food processor, they will all get you there in the end.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Katerina Holmes, Katerina Holmes, Klaus Nielsen, Andrea Piacquadio