Water content of salted butter
It seems to be common knowledge among bakers that salted butter has a higher water content than unsalted*. How much higher?
And if there's a different amount of water, why does this nutritional data say there's the same amount of fat in salted and unsalted butter? (I'm fairly sure I've seen the same on butter in the store, and I'll try to remember to confirm that next time I'm there.)
*I'm pretty sure I remember seeing the claim several places online, but the one I was able to quickly find is from Cook's Illustrated (click to expand the second-to-last question) via an answer here, saying that "salted butter almost always contains more water than unsalted butter". (It's possible that a lot of other people's knowledge ultimately came from there.) The nutritional information I've found, along with my own baking experience, does not back this up, but Cook's Illustrated is generally pretty trustworthy, hence the question.
Best Answer
The FDA definition for butter specifies only that it be made exclusively from cream or milk, contain a minimum of 80% butter fat by weight, and may include salt and coloring.
If you assume the butter in question is at the low end of the spectrum with exactly 80% fat and equal amounts of milk solids, then unsalted would have less water than salted. Since there is no standard that says milk solids must also be a specific percentage, or that fat content can only be 80% and no more, there is really no way to accurately make the claim that salted butter always contains more water than unsalted.
Pictures about "Water content of salted butter"
How much water does butter contain?
USDA commercial butter basics All U.S. butter must be at least 80 percent butterfat. (That leaves about 18 percent as water and 1 to 2 percent milk solids).Which butter has less water content?
European style butter (i.e. Kerrygold) has less water and is higher in fat, ranging from 82%-86%.Does butter have a high water content?
Most American butter on your grocer's shelf contains around 80 percent milk fat, which means it's about 16 to 18 percent water and 1 to 2 percent milk solids other than fat (sometimes referred to as curd).Does some butter have more water than others?
For a series of performance tests, we selected the butter with the highest fat content (Straus Family Creamery, at almost 86 percent), the butter with the lowest fat content and the highest water content (Land O' Lakes with 80 percent fat and almost 18 percent water) and our favorite table butter, Cremerie Classique ( ...Salted vs unsalted butter
More answers regarding water content of salted butter
Answer 2
I have read that by French law, salted butter is allowed a lower fat content. From the New York Times: Butter With a Pedigree. Ah, the French:
The most obvious difference is butterfat: By law, American butter must contain at least 80 percent, while the minimum for French butter is 82 percent (unless it is demi-sel, or salted butter, which can check in at 80 percent and include up to 2 percent salt). Two percentage points may sound measly, but since butterfat affects butter's flavor, texture and workability, every little bit counts.
This is speculation, but perhaps the folk wisdom of unsalted butter having higher fat content may have some basis in fact, at least outside of the US.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio, Tatiana Syrikova, Monstera