The role of fat (butter, oil) in caramel-required recipes?

I am coming rather late to this party, but here's my answer:

Caramel made by heating sugar in fat (oil or butter) will never completely harden like caramel made in water or just melting sugar and will get very soft again when reheated. Also, it is much easier to control the color of the caramel when made in fat.

In Chinese cuisine there is a process called "Red Braising" (Hong Shou). When red braising meats (typically fatty meats like pork belly), sugar is caramelized in oil until it is red (almost, but not quite brown) and then the meat is seared in the caramel. This gives it a rich, reddish, coating that does not harden. Imagine the dangerous splatter if you put fatty pork belly in a hot caramel made with water! There would be boiling sugar everywhere. Besides, it is very difficult to get red caramel when water or dry cooked.

So ... making caramel in oil is called for when you want a red color, or want a caramel that is deeply colored but will not completely harden. But be very careful and make it in a deep pot; splattering caramel is dangerous enough, but add boiling oil to the mix and it becomes doubly dangerous!

Well, I'd say it has mostly to do with texture, but also with taste.

To my knowledge there are three basic methods to making caramel:

• dry: without anything but sugar. In my opinion the most difficult method, as it tends to burn easily.
• wet: with water added to make sugar syrup, which is then turned into caramel. The water evaporates during the process. It takes a bit longer, but in my opinion definitely easier to handle than the dry method. Also, as i recall, has a slightly different texture than the dry method caramel.
• fatty: with fat, obviously. Fat doesn't evaporate and can get very hot, even though, not as hot as sugar alone. For me the easiest method. However, it should under no circumstances come in contact with water, or it get's very, very dangerous.

So in the first two cases you end up with mostly caramelized sugar and maybe water (depends on whether you let the water evaporate completely or if you try to end up with caramel sauce). With the third method, however, you end up with a caramel-fat mixture, which has of course different properties. For example, if it has enough fat, it turns soft again if it gets warm.

I think, for most of my applications, the fatty version gives a smoother, softer texture, which could indeed aid with the coating of nuts for example. This is probably, because most fats are soft or liquid when room temp. I think, it also affects taste, because fat is a natural flavor enhancer, which brings out the caramel flavor even more. Just like the salt in salted caramel. (On a side note, i think it also looks shinier, but that could just be my imagination. ;) )

As always with caramel: Be extra careful whichever method you're using. It is soooo fricking hot and you can burn yourself very, very easily. Stay safe!

Edit: for some extra science take a look at this paper I just found. It examines the effect of fat on caramel texture attributes. Might be interesting!

I wouldn't make a caramel with butter. I would add the butter once my caramel is ready, to stop it from cooking further. I think butter would burn before the sugar becomes caramel.

Good reasons to put butter/oil in caramel:

• Butter/oil comes in handy for coating nuts as it helps with them not sticking to one another.

• The fat can also prevent humidity from making your caramel disolve after being expose to the air for a while.

• Taste.