Some batter falls off during deep fry

Some batter falls off during deep fry - Heap of delicious crunchy fried potatoes spilled on table

I have been trying to replicate a bloomin' onion, but it seems that I can never keep the batter on the onion during the frying process. It doesn't completely fall off, but it is definitely not the same as what I see in restaurants.

I usually do a mixture of 2 eggs and a cup of milk for the wet and flour with spices for the dry. I dip in the wet first, then dry, wet again, then dry again. I fry it at 350, but when the time suggested (6 minutes) is up, I pull it out and it just seems to crumble off half the time.

Could it be that my oil is not the correct temperature? Am I leaving it in for the incorrect amount of time?

I am trying to follow the recipe found on food network's site.

Edit: As suggested by @Satanicpuppy I will try coating it in the flour mixture first, giving it a total of five dredgings. I will update this once I try it again if that is the solution.



Best Answer

From Alton Brown's I'm Just Here for the Food (p. 99): "The number one reason breadings fail (fall off) is too much primer coat (flour). There is nothing to hold the layers together so they unzip from each other and your breading is floating free in the fryer..."

If you're going to use a three-stage breading process, which is what you've described, you need to make sure to shake off as much of the initial flour layer as possible. Dry flour doesn't stick to itself very well, so if a too-thick initial dredging creates clump-like layers of flour that aren't well moistened, in the relative violence of the fryer the dry interior of those clump-like layers will separate from each other and your breading will flake off.

For "bloomin' onions," the process I've seen wasn't a three-stage one like you describe. Rather, the onions were stored/soaked in milk (because soaking in a slightly acidic liquid mellows the onions -- water should be as effective, and soaking may not be necessary at all), and, as needed, pulled out, shaken free of excess liquid, and generously dredged in seasoned flour.




Pictures about "Some batter falls off during deep fry"

Some batter falls off during deep fry - Waterfalls and Trees
Some batter falls off during deep fry - Battered Fried Dish with Dips on a Black Plate
Some batter falls off during deep fry - Picturesque view of bridge over river flowing among fading autumn trees in forest



Quick Answer about "Some batter falls off during deep fry"

  • You Don't Start Dry. The first step to breading chicken is crucial; make sure the chicken is completely dry before starting the dredging process. ...
  • Not Shaking Off the Flour. ...
  • Skimping on the Crumb. ...
  • Forgetting the Last Pat. ...
  • Being Impatient.


  • How do you keep the batter from falling when you fry?

    Fill one with a thick layer of cornstarch. Fill the second about one-third full of milk or milk substitute. Beat an egg into the milk until the mixture is smooth and creamy. Fill the third with a thick layer of flour, breadcrumbs or your coating of choice.

    Why does my batter come off when frying?

    Dry flour doesn't stick to itself very well, so if a too-thick initial dredging creates clump-like layers of flour that aren't well moistened, in the relative violence of the fryer the dry interior of those clump-like layers will separate from each other and your breading will flake off.

    Why did the batter fall off my fish?

    If the fish is dropped in the fryer to fast or even just tossed in the fryer the batter will most like disperse or just a little will stick. The secret here is to put in the fish slowly while giving it a little wiggle to get access batter off.



    Fry Fidelity: The Science Of Fried Chicken




    More answers regarding some batter falls off during deep fry

    Answer 2

    Most places use a wet batter for an onion:

    Outback Steakhouse Bloomin Onion
    
    4 Vidalia or Texas Sweet Onions
    
    Batter:
    1/3 Cup Cornstarch
    
    1 1/2 Cup Flour
    2 tsp. Garlic ?? minced 2 tsp. Paprika
    1 tsp. Salt
    1 tsp. Pepper
    24 oz. Beer
    
    Seasoned Flour:
    2 Cup Flour
    
    4 tsp. Paprika
    
    2 tsp. Garlic powder 1/2 tsp. Pepper
    1/4 tsp. Cayenne pepper
    
    Mix cornstarch, flour, and seasonings until well blended. Add beer,
    mix well. Cut about 3/4" off top of onion and peel. Cut into onion
    12 to 16 vertical wedges, but do not cut through bottom root end. Remove about 1" of                petals from center of onion. Dip onion in seasoned flour and remove excess by shaking. Separate petals and dip in batter to coat thoroughly. Gently place in fryer basket and deep?fry at
    
    375 to 400 1 1/2 minutes. Turn over, and fry an additional 1 1/2 minutes. Drain on paper towels.
    Place onion upright in shallow bowl and remove center core with circular cutter or apple     corer. Serve hot with Creamy Chili Sauce.
    
    Creamy Chili Sauce:
    1 pint Mayonnaise
    
    1 pint Sour cream
    
    1/2 Cup Chili sauce
    1/2 tsp. Cayenne pepper 
    

    Answer 3

    Try using Methylcellulose F50, it works very well to help a batter cling. You can see one way to do it using a pre-soak in this Fish & Chips Recipe - a 2% solution of F50 in water used as a dip before battering. I haven't tried it with onions, but I expect it would work well. Note that the methocel has to be well hydrated first.

    Answer 4

    Actually what I learned was after coating the onion with batter place the onion in the refrigerator for approximately 30 mins. Then take out and fry it. I tried it & it worked like a charm; the batter stuck very well

    Answer 5

    Fry the batter on a sausage to get the batter crispy, then slide the batter to the thing you want to put it on.

    You can cook the onion in a pan before putting in the batter, after this, you can cook the thing as a whole for about 5-10 mins. If you fry the onion as a whole, it should keep together as a whole, if this is what you want.

    Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

    Images: Satyam Verma, Ibrahim Boran, Polina Tankilevitch, Marta Wave