Non-beet alternatives to standard red food dye
I'd like to make a red colored cake for my red-head daughter's first birthday, and I would like a non-beet alternative way to dye it red. I've made red velvet cake before and the bug-based food coloring I used tasted and smelled awful. Plus I hear it can cause allergic reactions in young children.
I like beets, but I don't want a beet flavored cake so that alternative is out. Are there any other alternatives for a UK based amateur baker?
Best Answer
Red Velvet cake originally was a reddish brown from the natural processed cocoa (not Dutched) reacting with the baking soda. You can still make red velvet cake this way, but it will not have the glowing hue that dyes create.
You have to be sure not to use Dutch-processed cocoa powder as this has been pH neutralized and it is the acidity of natural cocoa powder that helps it retain its red color (which is caused by anthocyanins in the cocoa). Using buttermilk as the liquid in the recipe will help keep the environment acidic enough to be hospitable for the red coloring.
Hershey's and Nestle both sell natural cocoa powder.
Pictures about "Non-beet alternatives to standard red food dye"
How do you make red food coloring without beets?
Alternatives to Red Food ColoringWhat we can use instead of red food Colour?
Beets. Beet juice is a popular red food coloring substitute because it produces the best results out of other natural red food coloring substitutes.What can I use instead of food dye?
5 Alternatives to Red Food Coloring- Hibiscus flowers steeped in a bit of hot water until cooled.
- Boiled cranberries (as outlined at Stretcher.com)
- Red beet juice.
- Red beet powder.
- Pomegranate juice.
What is the least harmful food dye?
Blue #2 (Indigo Carmine): Although it's considered to be the least harmful of food dyes, studies have suggested that it has carcinogenic effects in mice and can worsen hyperactivity in children (2).100% Natural Homemade Red Food Color Recipe | For Restaurant Style Gravies \u0026 Indo Chinese Recipes
More answers regarding non-beet alternatives to standard red food dye
Answer 2
There do exist red food dyes that are specifically labeled vegan, and thus aren't insect-derived. Wilton also makes a 'no-taste red', which isn't as foul as the normal red color. I've personally found that the red liquid dyes tend to be less obnoxious than the gel-based ones, but I have no idea if other people feel that way, or if it holds true for all liquid dyes (and come to think of it, I was baking cookies with the liquid, while I use gels and powders for icing).
... but I have no idea if these might be available in your area or not. I'd try looking for a cake supply store, or even a bakery that makes cakes and see if they'll sell you some of their supply.
(and I personally was one of those with an extreme reaction to red food coloring (not sure if it's allergies or not) ... so I'm a bit sensitive to the subject.)
If you can't find prepared dyes specifically, I'd look into fruit ... you might not get as bright of a red, but pureed red fruit (strawberries, raspberries, cherries) might get you towards a red shade. If you're not in an area that gets the flown in shipments from the southern hemisphere (and thus out of season fruits), many large grocery stores sell frozen berries.
Answer 3
Order plant-based, non-petroleum liquid colors online from Chocolate Craft, Seelect, India Tree, or Maggie's Naturals.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Julia Filirovska, Pixabay, Engin Akyurt, Engin Akyurt