How careful do you have to be with adding flour for kneading?
When you're working a dough (kneading or rolling out), instructions often say to flour the surface you're working on and your rolling pin or hands. This helps the dough to stick less. However, I always am very careful that I don't use too much flour, because I'm afraid this will change the recipe. Is this fear irrational or would I need to use a lot to have an effect on the result? Is there a certain percentage of original amount of flour that you can't surpass?
I'm particularly asking about bread dough, but I think this will also apply to other doughs. I guess it would have more rapidly an effect on wetter doughs in general, but I'm not sure. So feel free to include broader answers.
Best Answer
Don't worry too much about it.
Be careful that some doughs are wet (high hydration - look at my question here), so they tend to stick more and are harder to manage.
If a dough is hard to manage, just let it sit in the fridge for a couple of hours. It will become tougher and easier to handle.
If you keep on adding flour, this will alter the bread formula (affecting the salt content and hydration), an additional percent or two flour won't make much of a difference.
Pictures about "How careful do you have to be with adding flour for kneading?"
Should you add flour while kneading?
Adding too much flour into your mixture will result in a very dry and extremely stiff dough. The dough will be too tight and tough to stretch when you attempt to pull it or roll it out. Overfloured dough could become crumbly and break and fall apart during the kneading process.Can you add too much flour when kneading?
For most recipes, it's hard to over-knead your dough by hand, but you do risk overheating it, and that could prematurely kickstart proofing. Follow the recipe and don't be afraid to push your dough around a bit\u2014you've gotta get that gluten in line.Is there a wrong way to knead dough?
The Dough Passes the Windowpane Test To do this, tear off a chunk of dough and stretch it between your fingers. If the dough tears, you haven't developed enough gluten and it needs more kneading. If it stretches without breaking, making a windowpane of sorts, you're done and you can let the dough rest.23: Are you adding flour when kneading your dough? - Bake with Jack
More answers regarding how careful do you have to be with adding flour for kneading?
Answer 2
At the end of the day, you need to use as much flour as necessary to ensure the dough is not sticking. It's a lot worse to deal with a dough that is stuck to a pin or that is stuck to the table. The only time I've ever been told to watch how much flour to use for dusting was when I went to school, and that is because my teacher was a cheap old bugger (or so I thought at the time). Throughout the day, we would scrape this excess dusting flour into a container, and always reuse it into new doughs. As I said, at the time I thought it was cheap, but when i started running my own shops, I always did this too, any bit to help the old G.P.
However, realistically, you needn't worry about using too much dusting flour.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Andrea Piacquadio