Are soft boiled eggs and poached eggs identical?
Today I heard from a friend, that poached eggs are simply glorified soft-boiled eggs and that there is no way to distinguish between the two except for the form. The only reason anyone does poached eggs is because soft-boiled eggs are kind of hard to peel.
He then told me that you can make a hole in an egg, soft boil it, than because of the small hole you can peel it easily basically eliminating the main disadvantage of soft-boiled eggs: difficulty when peeling.
The result is supposed to be identical to a poached egg.
I have had both soft-boiled eggs and poached eggs many times, and I always felt that poached eggs have a unique taste and texture.
Or is the hole in the egg mimicking the poaching because it lets water in?
You are supposed to make the hole on the flatter side of the egg, where the air pocket is.
Best Answer
I'll answer the question in your title. Poached eggs are eggs, removed from the shell when raw, and cooked in a liquid. The consistency of the yolk can vary depending on the poaching time. The consistency of the white is generally the same each time. Poaching usually happens at a temperature below the boil.
Soft (or medium, or hard) boiled eggs are eggs that are left in the shell, but cooked in boiling water. The assumption in the comments, that the cooking is stopped before heat reaches the yolk, in not correct. Soft boiled eggs can certainly have yolks of varying consistency, it is just that they are not hard. The white, is of course, protected by the shell to some degree, so the consistency can vary depending on the cooking time. It is often more done near the shell, and of a looser consistency as it approaches the yolk.
Egg yolks and whites are very sensitive to cooking time and temperature, so small variations produce different results. In addition, the yolk and white behave differently. It is why many have found cooking eggs sous vide so interesting.
So, yes, the processes produce different results and should not be considered the same.
Pictures about "Are soft boiled eggs and poached eggs identical?"
Quick Answer about "Are soft boiled eggs and poached eggs identical?"
The only advantage poached eggs have over soft-boiled is that they lay flatter — and are roughly the same diameter as an English muffin. But soft-boiled eggs are superior in every other respect: they are easier, cleaner, and more consistent than poached eggs. You can also cook them in larger batches.Are poached eggs and soft boiled eggs the same?
1) poached egg is done without the shell while soft boiled with the shell, 2) soft boiled egg can be done with a combination of aggressive temperature and fine controlled timing, while poached egg is done with fine controlled temperature and relaxed timing.Are poached and boiled the same?
Food item is kept submerged under hot water in both poaching and boiling, and the only difference is that of temperature of water. Boiling takes place at 212 degrees Fahrenheit, whereas for poaching the temperature is kept at around 160 to 180 degrees Fahrenheit.What is the difference between soft boiled and hard boiled eggs?
While hard-boiled eggs are started in cold water, brought to a boil, and then removed from the heat to finish cooking, soft-boiled eggs are lowered into boiling water and gently boiled until done.What is the difference between a poached egg and a basted egg?
Basted Eggs \u2013 Similar to sunny side up, but the top is cooked by spooning hot fat from the pan over the eggs. This can also be done with water or other liquid for a version that is lower in fat. Poached \u2013 Cooked without the shell in simmering liquid, usually water.An Omelette, Poached Egg \u0026 Soft Boiled Egg In 8 Minutes! | MasterChef Canada | MasterChef World
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: ANTONI SHKRABA, Klaus Nielsen, Jana Ohajdova, Alena Koval