Why does my butter icing melt so quickly?

Why does my butter icing melt so quickly? - Selective Focus Photography of Cupcakes

I've been making cupcakes for a while now and I use butter icing. They come out pretty and taste nice, but they melt so quickly. Sometimes it's impossible to pipe, because the icing goes so sloppy. When I go to parties and see other cupcakes, they stay on the table all day and the icing doesn't melt.

Are they using something different? If so, does anyone know what?



Best Answer

Many frostings incorporate more than butter as the fat in the icing. I recently made ones using shortening, coconut butter, and coconut milk solids. These three are all fats that have higher melting points and are more reliable at higher temperatures in comparison to butter.

If you wish to retain as much of the butter mouthfeel as possible, you might consider switching to a buttercream mixture that splices in shortening or even margarine as both are more workable at room temperature. You might also try some of the other variations on buttercream.

Best practices for icing or frosting in any case are all over the web;


  • As alluded to in the comments, don't put meltable frosting/icing on a hot cake.
  • If you are going to keep the frosting in the heat and sunlight, you are definitely going to want to add some shortening or coconut butter in there; that's why it's called Decorator's icing, they put shortening in it so it can hang out at summer weddings.



Pictures about "Why does my butter icing melt so quickly?"

Why does my butter icing melt so quickly? - Shallow Focus Photography of Chocolate Cupcakes
Why does my butter icing melt so quickly? - A Round Chocolate Cake on a Ceramic Cake Stand
Why does my butter icing melt so quickly? - Slice of Orange and Ice Blocks



Why does my buttercream always melt?

If your buttercream looks like it's falling off the cake or your piped decorations begin to droop, it's very likely the temperature in the room is too hot, causing your buttercream to melt.

How do you keep icing from melting while piping?

Buttercream melts from the warmth of your hands as you're piping along. Trick is to keep your hands as cool as possible or have two bags so they can be swapped over as one begins to soften. Keep the bags cool.

How do you get buttercream to harden?

By bringing down the temperature, the frosting should tighten up immediately. This is a great trick for buttercream frosting that may have been overmixed or made in a warm kitchen. If this doesn't seem to do the trick, try adding sifted powdered sugar, a few tablespoons at a time.



All About Buttercream Consistency | How to Fix Buttercream That's Too Stiff or Too Soft




More answers regarding why does my butter icing melt so quickly?

Answer 2

I usually add vegetable shortening to my frosting recipe so that it doesn't melt easily. I live in India and it's hot in here for crying out loud. Another helpful tip is to add 2 tsp Meringue powder to your each icing batch, that tends to avoid the weepy icing.

Hope this helps.

(Source: Years of commercial bakery experience and my fair lot of sad weepy but delicious cupcakes)

Answer 3

Once I had such a problem so I thought of adding some All purpose flour to it. It somewhat stiffens.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Lukas, Acharaporn Kamornboonyarush, Denys Gromov, Pixabay