Why do some recipes call for sugar in a brine?
In making a brine for my chicken, I came across a lot of recipes that call for sugar in the brine. I understand the general idea behind brining, but don't understand what benefit the sugar provides.
In this answer, @papin links to a PDF that states the following (emphasis mine):
The law of diffusion states that the salt and sugar will naturally flow from the area of greater concentration (the brine) to lesser concentration (the cells). There is also a greater concentration of water, so to speak, outside of the turkey than inside. Here, too, the water will naturally flow from the area of greater concentration (the brine) to lesser concentration (the cells). When water moves in this fashion, the process is called osmosis. Once inside the cells, the salt and, to a lesser extent, the sugar cause the cell proteins to unravel, or denature. As the individual proteins unravel, they become more likely to interact with one another. This interaction results in the formation of a sticky matrix that captures and holds moisture.
This makes it sound like sugar isn't really an important part of the osmosis process.
Is there a chemical/molecular reason to add the sugar, or is it just to add some flavor to the chicken breast?
Best Answer
The sugar is simply used for flavoring; the fact that it helps brine to a lesser extent is just an added bonus. The sugar also aids in browning via the Maillard reaction, though this can also result in burning in a high heat application.
I suggest brining two boneless skinless chicken breasts -- one in a salt-only brine and the other with the salt & sugar brine suggested by Cook's Illustrated. You should notice a difference in both flavor and appearance.
Pictures about "Why do some recipes call for sugar in a brine?"
Quick Answer about "Why do some recipes call for sugar in a brine?"
The sugar is simply used for flavoring; the fact that it helps brine to a lesser extent is just an added bonus. The sugar also aids in browning via the Maillard reaction, though this can also result in burning in a high heat application.Why do you put sugar in a brine?
Adding sugar to brine will help with browning The sugar will help ensure perfect browning of the meat's skin while adding a sweet flavor. The site notes that sugar does not change the texture.What does sugar do in a dry brine?
Along with salt, sugar (either brown or white granulated) is a dry-brine must-have, essential both for its browning capabilities and flavor-enhancing properties. Breaking out the sugar is my favorite way to ensure that my turkey comes out perfectly tender and golden brown every November.Can you use regular sugar for brine?
While water is water, and salt, salt (actually there's many different types of salt, but for a brine I'd just use regular kosher salt), you can definitely have some fun with the sugar. White table sugar is just fine to use, but brown sugar carries a different flavor, as does honey, molasses, and maple syrup.What does sugar and salt brine do?
The salt relaxes the protein making it more tender. The salt also increases the amount of water in the meat making it more juicy. The sugar in the brine is important to help balance out the harshness of the salt.More answers regarding why do some recipes call for sugar in a brine?
Answer 2
Sugar is for seasoning. While the law of diffusion does indeed say that a solute (sugar, salt) will flow down its concentration gradient from and area of high concentration to an area of low concentration there is one fact you seem to negate which is the cell membrane within which the muscle proteins are encased. The cell membrane is impermeable to passive transport by diffusion of salt and sugar. Both these substances must be actively transported into the cell. So in a live organism water (which can easily pass in and out of cell through aquaporin proteins) would leave the cell and eventually crenate (dehydrate). However, since this animal is no longer living the cell membranes have broken down to some degree and the barrier to salt transport is relieved. The salt solution would disrupt cell membrane transport proteins and sort of punch holes in the muscle tissue allowing salt and sugar tot enter. The salt will interfere with the chemical bonding that keeps the muscle proteins shaped the way they need to be to function. This is called denaturing. The unfolded protein can now form bonds with the Cl and Na ions and water will form hydration shells around the proteins thus hydrating the meat.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Monstera, Valeria Boltneva, Katerina Holmes, Karolina Grabowska