Why aren't my macarons as soft as professional ones?
I recently bought some macarons made by professional bakeries. When I got home, I threw them into the freezer and, days later, I checked on them. When I took a bite, it was still nice and soft. The cold temperature seemed to have had no effect whatsoever on the product. It was as tasty and supple as if it had been left out at room temperature.
The macarons that I make don't do this though. When they come out of the freezer, they're just crunchy. If I leave them out to thaw at room temperature, then they do soften up, but the store-bought ones don't need to thaw at all. I'd like for mine to do this as well. How can I keep my macarons soft while they're also being frozen?
Best Answer
I believe this has more to do with different ingredients in the "professional" category. Modern professional bakeries(whether industrial sized or not) often have access to a wide variety of additives, some of which are not even required to be listed on the "ingredients" list specifically. This varies widely by country; common euphimistic examples of such ingredients in a very general sense include words like "spices", "emulsifiers", "softeners", "stabilizers", "anti-caking agents", or "preservatives".
I would suspect a hydrophilic substance first. Commonly used "softeners" are various plant based gums and fiber. Think guar gum, xanthan gum, inulin, cellulose, or psyllium husk. A cookie which I know to be very high in one or more of these softeners is known across the U.S.A. as "Chips A'hoy Chewy". These cookies tend to stay softer in almost any condition, from frozen to relatively dried out/stale, than home made cookies.
All of these potential ingredients are available for the home chef today(including many I have not mentioned), but would not be typically found in your kitchen or at your local grocer. You would want to look at a shop or online vendor specializing in "molecular gastronomy".
One of the things I do with cookies in general(which would not work very well with anything frozen, but I feel the need to mention anyway) is to place a slice of bread into an airtight storage container with fresh cookies after the cookies have cooled to room temperature. This will keep almost any kind of cookie softer than other storage methods, while the slice of bread will seem to have dried out significantly by comparison. This precludes the use of additives entirely. I suspect this probably also carries a higher spoilage risk, due to the addition of humidity, although I've not had any issues with cookies spoiling this way before they are eaten(usually within about 5 days). Refrigeration would help tremendously if there was a desire to keep them far longer, although I would not recommend freezing.
All that said, I have little experience with macaroons, specifically, so your experience may vary.
Pictures about "Why aren't my macarons as soft as professional ones?"
Why are my macarons not soft?
Macaron Troubleshooting Issue #5: Why Are My Macarons Crispy/Hard? Sometimes if your batter is overmixed it causes your shells to spread more and bake up crispy. They may also just be overbaked! Keep in mind that macaron shells soften once they're filled and have time to mature in the fridge.Why are my macarons so hard?
Leave them in the fridge and let them continue to rest, they should soften some more over time! Exactly how long it takes depends on how hard/crunchy the shells are and the consistency of the filling, but I've had some macarons that took about a week in the fridge before they got to a nice texture.How can I soften my macarons?
The most common cause of a macaron turning out too chewy is that it has been overbaked. Essentially, you might have kept your macarons in the oven just a bit too long if they are turning out much chewier than they should be.AND WHY AREN'T YOU IN UNIFORM ? | TIKTOK COMPILATION
More answers regarding why aren't my macarons as soft as professional ones?
Answer 2
Macarons are dough you have to follow the recipe exactly. If it says room temperature eggs use room temperature. If it says to sift the almond flour 3 times do that. Also, make sure not to over fold or stir the mixture.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Monstera, Monstera, Klaus Nielsen, Anete Lusina