Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed]

Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed] - Close-Up Shot of Collapsible Cups

I'd like a reusable lightweight cup for the microwave, so I compare the melting temperature of plastics (#1 through #6 in our recycling codes) and would think Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET) is the best

So, why is Polypropylene (PP) predominantly used instead? I would even guess PET is cheaper to manufacture since most one-time bottles are PET. Is it really just a public perception preference for PP?



Best Answer

I'd guess there are many factors. For instance, in manufacturing, small differences in raw material cost and process requirements can have a big impact.

However, in this case, I'd say it comes down to temperature resistance: polyester (PET or PETE) does not do well at high temperatures, PP does. A reusable cup for microwave use is going to have hot (probably boiling) liquid in it.

From Plastic bottle - Wikipedia:

Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET, PETE or polyester) is commonly used for carbonated beverage, water bottles and many food products. ... This material does not provide resistance to very high temperature applications—max. temp. 200 °F (93 °C).

Polypropylene (PP) is used primarily for jars and closures and provides a rigid package with excellent moisture barrier. One major advantage of polypropylene is its stability at high temperatures, up to 220 °F (104 °C). Polypropylene is autoclavable and offers the potential for steam sterilization. The compatibility of PP with high filling temperatures is responsible for its use with hot fill products. PP has excellent chemical resistance, but provides poor impact resistance in cold temperatures.

Here's an additional source: The 7 Most Common Plastics and How They are Typically Used. In summary: PETE is easily recyclable but breaks down under both heat and light exposure. So it gets used for one-time-use applications but isn't suitable for reusable containers.




Pictures about "Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed]"

Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed] - Close-Up Shot of a Person Holding a Collapsible Cup
Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed] - Close-Up Shot of Collapsible Cups
Why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed] - Colorful Silicone Cup Lids on White Surface





The Reusable Cup Problem: A solution




More answers regarding why are there no PETE reusable cups? [closed]

Answer 2

Depending where you live there are plenty of cheap PET recyclable cups?

Cheap PP and PET cups are made by partially punching circles in a continuous sheet of raw plastic, and then these circles are heat punched into cup shapes. The vertical stress lines on PET (a harder material) will open up with hot liquids

PET will also start to deform above 90°C. Otherwise, yes PET is a better material and easier to recycle

Both PP and PET can be fully recycled, or burnt as hydrocarbon fuel

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Polina Tankilevitch, Polina Tankilevitch, Polina Tankilevitch, cottonbro