Whiskey sour: should the bourbon kill any germs in the egg whites?
Inspired by the TV show Mad Men, my wife and I made whiskey sours, which were really delicious. We followed the standard recipe, which includes a couple of ounces of bourbon and roughly half an egg white. We're not dead yet, but anyway, is it scientifically reasonable to believe that the bourbon would kill any germs present in the egg white? (I assume the lemon juice also makes it a very acidic environment.)
Best Answer
The alcohol is not enough to kill germs in your beverage. Typically alcohol content necessary for killing germs is between 60% and 95%.
Straight bourbon will not approach that.
You're "not dead yet" because the food supply is generally very safe, though consuming truly raw eggs is counter to FDA and USDA recommendations.
A recommendation compliant alternative to raw eggs is to use pasteurized eggs, which in my experience work just fine in cocktails.
Pictures about "Whiskey sour: should the bourbon kill any germs in the egg whites?"
Quick Answer about "Whiskey sour: should the bourbon kill any germs in the egg whites?"
The alcohol is not enough to kill germs in your beverage. Typically alcohol content necessary for killing germs is between 60% and 95%. Straight bourbon will not approach that.Is egg white safe in a whiskey sour?
Here's how to make a Whiskey Sour Recipe with Egg White! This classic way to top drinks is perfectly safe and has been a tradition for hundreds of years. Your whiskey sour just got better.Can you use pasteurized egg whites in a whiskey sour?
Pasteurized egg whites from a jar or powdered egg whites are in no way a reasonable substitute. Now back to the glory. You can add an egg white to any sour-style cocktail, including a Whiskey Sour, White Lady or Pisco Sour. (Use the yolk for an omelet.)Can egg white in a drink make you sick?
The sours drinks, which contain spirits like whiskey, gin or pisco, as well as lemon juice, syrup and ice, are mixed with raw egg white. Bartenders do this to give the drink a silkier texture and a frothy head on the top. But eggs can carry salmonella bacteria, which cause unpleasant food poisoning.Is a whiskey sour unhealthy?
While none are exactly nutritional superstars, a classic whiskey sour made with real ingredients like lemon juice, sugar, and egg whites clocks in at around 175 calories, which isn't so bad.Whiskey Sour with Egg Whites
More answers regarding whiskey sour: should the bourbon kill any germs in the egg whites?
Answer 2
Its kind of interesting as these questions actually relate to one another.
Question A: Will bourbon kill the germs in egg whites?
In short, kind-of, sort-of. Alcohol will inherently deprive germs of the oxygen/hydrogen that they need to survive and reproduce, but the most effective disinfectants contain at least 60% alcohol. A far cry from your typical 70 proof bourbon (35% alcohol). That being said, any portion of the egg white that comes in contact with the bourbon (assuming 1 shot bourbon to 1 egg white) will have the germs drastically inhibited, just like you after a few whiskey sours!
Question 2: Am I getting the protein from the egg white.
This answer is easy. Yes. In the same way that the lime in ceviche does not kill the protein in the shrimp, whiskey, which is inherently acidic, does not destroy the protein in the egg.
But this is where it gets interesting, and, as far as I know, we are outside the world of observed science (at least a little bit).
Being an acid, whiskey would break apart the molecular structure of the egg proteins. This is what happens when you marinade the bird is brine, or cook the shrimp in ceviche, we are breaking apart the surface level of proteins to allow the brine/marinade to work its way into the meat. Also, being an astringent, the whiskey also deprives the germs in the egg of their necessary resources. Though I do not know if any studies on whiskey vs egg has been done, in theory, the acids in the whiskey should break down the egg while also disinfecting anything found inside the egg at the same time. In function, it should function like washing your hands in soap whilst dousing them in isopropyl.
If anyone knows of a study on alcohol on loose proteins, please let me know!
That being said, if you are enjoying your whiskey sours in the USA, Britain, Germany, or practically any northern European country, there is no reason to worry about getting anything from an egg white. I'd be more worried about the hangover.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Kelly L, Moussa Idrissi, Dziana Hasanbekava, Wendy Wei