What are the differences between different types of onions, and when do you use them?
I used a recipe for a mean black-eyed-pea salad this past weekend which called for a red onion. Since I wanted extra onion flavor in the salad anyway, I decided to pick up a Vidalia onion to throw in as well.
As I was prepping the salad, I got thinking that I didn't know why the original recipe called for a red onion and what adding a different type of onion would do to the salad.
What do different types of onions add to a recipe and when might it be best to use type over another?
Best Answer
The choice of one onion over another is really going to come down to personal preference based on color and flavor.
Red and white onions are usually milder in flavor than yellow onions which is the reason they're often the choice for hamburgers and sandwiches.
Yellow (sometimes referred to as "Spanish") onions tend to have a more pungent flavor.
Sweet onions (Vidalia, Maui, Walla-Walla, Texas 1015) develop more sweetness and fewer sulfuric compounds due to the mineral content of the soil that they're grown in. This is why you can have onion sets (small bulbs) from any of these varieties but they won't necessarily be sweet (or as sweet) because a lot of it has to do with the makeup of the soiling they're grown in.
Two years ago I hosted Jeanne Jones (syndicated writer of "Cook it Light" column for King Features syndicate and writer of over 33 cookbooks including "Canyon Ranch Spa Cookbook") for guest chef cooking classes. If I recall correctly, she said she used primarily white onions because they have a lower sodium content than any other type.
Did that "mean black eyed pea salad" recipe happen to come from a certain "Low Country Cooking Class"? If so, I used it for two reasons: not everyone will have access to Vidalia onions and it provides additional color.
Pictures about "What are the differences between different types of onions, and when do you use them?"
What is the difference between different types of onions?
White Onions: A stronger, spicier, more pungent flavour than yellow onions. More oniony, for lack of a better term, than yellow onions. They don't hold up as well when cooked, as they tend to fall apart. Red Onions: The salad onion.How do you know which onion to use?
The good folks at WonderHowTo give us a quick look at what types of onions are good for different preparations.Which onions are best for cooking?
What are the 4 types of onions?
Here's what you need to know about the different types of onions:- (1) Storage Onions. ...
- Yellow Onions. ...
- Red Onions. ...
- White Onions. ...
- (2) Softies. ...
- Sweet Onions. ...
- Green Onions. ...
- Spring Onions.
More answers regarding what are the differences between different types of onions, and when do you use them?
Answer 2
Here is a visual guide to identifying and using different onion varieties from Epicurious. They break it down like this:
- Yellow Onions (Spanish onions): Mild but not sweet
- White Onions : Tangy flavor
- Red Onions: Sharpest of the common onion varieties
- Sweet Onions (Vidalia, Bermuda): Sweet and very mild
Answer 3
Red onion tends to be milder, and more suited to eating raw than white onions. Of course, in salads, red onions can add a bit extra visually as well.
Answer 4
While I like the other answers, keep in mind in your case since you're looking to add more onion flavor to the dish that there are alternatives from the typical onions already mentioned.
You can also try more subtle onion flavors from scallions (or green onions) or shallots. For the salad it might make more sense to go with the scallions.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Jonathan Borba, Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio