Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs

Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs - Person Holding Stainless Steel Fork and Bread Knife

I wish to know what would be the difference between using only egg yolks in a pudding, compared to using whole eggs?

Yes, there are other questions on this site, asking what is the difference between yolks and whites, but I wish to know if it would be different in a pudding.

(I mean this type of pudding pic)

(link to example recipe)



Best Answer

Depending on the recipe and procedures, there will be no discernible difference.

So, yes, you can use whole eggs for this type of recipe. I was trained to do this by a well respected chef, and I still use whole eggs for several of my egg based items (eg. Creme Anglaise, Creme Patissiere, etc).

Here is an example recipe that appears to be quite safe in its procedures which can easily be applied to your recipe: https://www.melskitchencafe.com/the-best-vanilla-pudding/

Personally, I would use them at ratio 1:1, so as your recipe has 3 eggs yolks I would use 3 whole eggs.

For procedures:

  • After heating the milk, split the hot milk in half amounts.
  • Temper the whisked eggs (that already have some cold milk mixed with them) by slowly whisking in one half of the hot milk, and put the egg mixture aside.
  • Cook the remaining half of the hot milk with the cornstarch and sugar (etc).
  • Once the cornstarch mixture has thickened and simmered for several minutes, while whisking, slowly add it to the tempered egg mixture.
  • Put the complete mixture back on the stove over moderate heat.
  • While stirring to ensure the mixture doesn't stick to the bottom, raise the temperature of the mixture until you can see faint wisps of steam above the mixture (this could be difficult to see).
  • Once you see the faint wisps of steam, you must be careful as this is the point where the eggs will begin to thicken.
  • Cook the mixture without scrambling the eggs. (So just light bubbling simmer is enough, no need to try to boil profusely)



Pictures about "Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs"

Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs - Slice of Eggs on Cakes
Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs - Top view of chicken eggs in rows in paper container placed on table for cooking
Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs - Sunny Side Up Eggs On White Ceramic Plate



Quick Answer about "Using eggs in pudding - yolks vs whole eggs"

With the eggs, the issue is whether to use the whole egg or only the yolk. Yolks give a richer tasting, velvety custard, and a deeper yellow colour which is more appetising. If you add whites there is more of a jellyish consistency. Whites make a sturdier custard and are useful if you wish to unmould a baked custard.

Can I use whole eggs instead of egg yolks in pudding?

You certainly can replace the yolks with whole eggs but you wouldn't do one-to-one as that would give you too much volume. The average egg has more volume in whites than in yolks (it's about 60% white and 30% yolk) so you'd want to use three whole eggs, not six.

What happens if you use egg yolks instead of whole eggs?

Whole eggs do a bit of both. Based on this understanding of what the different parts do, our guess is that substituting a whole egg with two yolks would give us a very tender and moist cookie with a cake-like structure. Because we lose the proteins in the whites, the cookie would likely be crumbly.

Are puddings are thickened by egg yolks?

Puddings and CustardsCustards are thickened with the power of eggs. Some use yolks, some use whole eggs, some use a mixture of yolks and eggs. Regardless, unless it contains eggs, it's not technically a custard. Since eggs are so versatile, there are lots of ways to cook them.

What happens if I use whole egg instead of egg white?

Betty Crocker mix says: add the whole egg and don't change anything else. That means 1 egg for every 1 egg white. This will make a softer cake after baked. But it will also yellow the cake mix.



LECHE FLAN RECIPE || WHOLE EGGS VS EGG YOLKS ONLY ||CLASSIC RECIPE




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: ROMAN ODINTSOV, Trang Doan, Klaus Nielsen, ROMAN ODINTSOV