Should traditional moule marinier have cream in it?
I'm about to make moule marinier and was surprised to see a lot of the recipes had cream in them. I'm sure I remember watching an episode of Celebrity Masterchef where they had to prepare moule marinier and the judges being surprised at the people who put cream in the dish.
As it is supposedly a sailors dish, and I can't imagine sailors having fresh cream to hand it seems unlikely that they would traditionally contain cream. Is this right? Should moule marinier have cream in it? Or should I just finish the cooking liquor with a knob of butter at the end?
Best Answer
Traditional Moules a la mariniere is finished by reducing the cooking liquid until it is concentrated and then "mounting" it with butter (monter au beurre).
Mouclade is a traditional mussel preparation from the region of Bordeaux where the cooking liquid is enriched at the end with heavy cream and sometimes egg yolks, thus the reason the judges on your show were commenting that the cream was incorrect.
Pictures about "Should traditional moule marinier have cream in it?"
Quick Answer about "Should traditional moule marinier have cream in it?"
Without the cream, the flavour of the mussels and the wine can really shine: Rick Stein's recipe seems rich but dull in comparison.How do you make Moule Frite?
MethodHow do you serve moules mariniere?
Read the full disclosure policy here. An enormous pot of steaming mussels marini\xe8res arrives before you\u2026....How To Eat Mussels Like The FrenchWhat is classic moules?
Classic Moules Frites, a traditional preparation of mussels cooked with shallots, garlic, white wine, cream, and parsley and served with homemade French fries.What is Marinière?
French (\u02ccm\xe6r\u026an\u026a\u02c8j\u025b\u0259 ) adjective. (of shellfish) served in white wine and onion sauce.More answers regarding should traditional moule marinier have cream in it?
Answer 2
I live in one of the main mussel producing areas in France and anyone putting cream in moules marinieres would be crucified. They would then become moules à la creme, NOT marinieres.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Jill Wellington, Lukas, Tofros.com, Meli Di Rocco