Should I separate grape skins when making jam?
Recipes for grape jam (e.g. from Gourmet) commonly say to separate the skins, puree the skins for inclusion in the jam, cook them, cook the pulp, and remove the seeds with a food mill.
Is there any reason one couldn't instead just cook the entire grapes for long enough for everything to intermingle (i.e. long enough to fully cook the skins), then use a food mill to remove the seeds and skins?
Best Answer
I did actually do two batches with the two methods within a few weeks of asking the question.
Just cooking it all together, then removing the skins and seeds with a food mill, is definitely a lot faster. Removing the skins first then pureeing, so that you only remove the seeds later... well, though it is easy to remove the skin from each individual grape, time-consuming is an understatement unless you're making small quantities. It took me a few hours for (if I recall correctly) 10-15 pounds of grapes.
Including the skins has a moderate effect on the texture - it's slightly thicker and more opaque. You get the feeling there's just more stuff in it. As long as you're cooking it fairly long, though, there's not a very noticeable difference in flavor. On the other hand, if you're using a recipe with pectin instead of cooking it down until it sets, I definitely prefer having the skins in, for both flavor and texture.
So there's some personal preference involved; I do rather like the texture with the pureed skins. But if you're doing large quantities, and the grapes are on the small side, and you don't have help, you might want to skip it.
Pictures about "Should I separate grape skins when making jam?"
How do you separate grape pulp from skin?
Separate the skin from the pulp of each grape, by applying pressure to the grape with your thumb and index finger, shooting the pulp right out. It's fun and very simple to do. Process the grape skins with the sugar in your food processor or blender until mostly smooth but still a tad bit chunky.How do you peel grapes for jam?
Start by peeling back a bit of the grape skin from one end of the grape and then squeeze out the inside. The grape pulp goes into one bowl and the peels go into another. I know, peeling grapes sounds tedious. So is shelling peas and all manner of tasks grandma filled her days with staying useful.What is the best way to Deseed grapes?
StepsHow do I extract the juice from grapes to make jelly?
Extracting the JuiceHow To Separate Grape Skins
More answers regarding should I separate grape skins when making jam?
Answer 2
Most of the recipes I see that call for the skins to be pureed and added into the jam call for a longer time on the stove for the skins, so they probably need more time on the stove in order to achieve a proper texture and flavor. That Gourmet recipe also calls for maceration in order to develop more flavor.
The seeds are removed after the jam is cooked (not before as you imply in your question), because grape seeds are not something you want to crunch on while eating your jam and toast.
I assume you could mash all of the grapes, cook, and then mill, however - that might not cook the skins enough, and they would probably ultimately be removed from the final product, which would be different from the recipe above which includes them in the jam.
Removing concord grapes from the skin is incredibly easy, all you have to do is squeeze the grapes. Sure it's a bit time consuming, but it's not as bad as pitting cherries!
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Kevin Menajang, Kevin Menajang, cottonbro, Tima Miroshnichenko