Protein in cooked vs. raw chicken breast filet
I'm a bit confused by the label on an uncooked versus a cooked chicken breast. Both mention 23g of protein per 100 g of product:
If I cook the raw chicken myself, it loses a lot of water, so after cooking it only weighs 80% of what it used to weigh, and as none of the protein evaporated, my cooked chicken now contains 23g of protein per 80g, (28.75g / 100g) whereas the store-bought cooked chicken has 23g of protein per 100g
Where does this discrepancy come from?
Best Answer
Proteins are complex chemical forms so it depends. Let me elaborate by giving 2 extreme examples:
- If you boil an egg, the proteins unfold, hook into one another and therefore a liquid becomes a solid that doesn't melt again when you cool it down and there is no protein loss whatsoever.
- if you burn a piece of chicken breast fillet to a crisp on a barbecue overnight, a lot of protein mass will be lost.
In your particular case, I see the following possibilities:
- there is an error in the label of one of the products and they probably did not send off their product for actual testing, but took their ingredient list from a database.
- the cooked chicken is encased in a batter and the end product just happens to have the same protein content as the uncooked chicken.
You should contact a local consumer protection program and have them send off both products for actual testing as these kinds of tests are quite expensive.
As your labels are German, I advise: https://www.test.de
Pictures about "Protein in cooked vs. raw chicken breast filet"
Quick Answer about "Protein in cooked vs. raw chicken breast filet"
Chicken breast has 78 percent more protein than raw chicken – raw chicken contains 17.4 grams of protein per 100 grams of weight, whereas chicken breast contains 31 grams of protein per 100 grams of weight.Does cooked chicken breast have more protein than raw?
Beef, Chicken and Other Meats A 4-ounce skinless chicken breast boasts 23 grams of protein. Studies on the effects of cooking on meat have not shown significant changes in protein value, according to the American Meat Science Association.Does cooked chicken have the same protein as raw chicken?
If you cook a 100 g piece of chicken with 23 g of protein, you will end up with a piece of chicken with 23 g of protein. It will now be less than 100 g due to moisture loss.Does the amount of protein in chicken change when cooked?
Figures from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's nutrient database show that the uncooked meat from a 1-pound chicken contains 51 grams of protein. That same chicken, after being stewed or simmered, contains 49 grams of protein for a net loss of 2 grams.Does chicken breast lose protein when cooked?
In general, meat, poultry and fish will shrink about 25 percent when cooked. Sixteen ounces (1 pound) of raw boneless, skinless chicken breast will therefore yield about 12 ounces of cooked chicken.Should I Weigh My Meat Cooked or Raw? | Which Macros Are Correct?
More answers regarding protein in cooked vs. raw chicken breast filet
Answer 2
I think the confusion is in interpretation of the label. If you cook a 100g piece of chicken with 23g of protein, you will end up with a piece of chicken with 23g of protein. It will now be less than 100g due to moisture loss.
As Cynetta points out, the amount of moisture lost will depend on how much it is cooked. It stands to reason that if you have 100g after cooking, the protein content will be higher, but how much is based on the starting amount.
So, using the numbers provided in the question, you started with 600g of chicken, containing 138g of protein. (6 x 23 = 138) After cooking you had 460g of chicken. So, per 100 grams of cooked chicken, there are 30g of protein. (138 / 4.6 = 30)
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Mateusz Dach, Sarah Chai, Klaus Nielsen, Klaus Nielsen