My éclair (pâte à choux) was doughy
I followed the Pierre Hermé éclairs recipe:
60mL water
75mL whole milk
3g salt
3g caster sugar
56g butter
75g flour
A little over 2 eggs
I did the recipe and it called for 45 minutes of baking at 185°C.
I baked them for 40 minutes and left them in the oven for an extra 10 minutes before removing them.
The result was that the exterior was terrific, but the inside was too doughy and I couldn't fill it with crème pâtissière (custard).
Is skipping the 5 last minutes of baking the reason it failed?
Best Answer
I'm fairly certain that the last 5 minutes of baking would not have opened the texture of the interior.
Pâte à Choux is supposed to be very soft inside. It has ribbons of eggy material running through it. That is why cream puffs are usually scooped out before filling.
The material is very tender so, with eclairs, injecting the filling pushes it out of the way and the shell is firm enough to hold in the pressure.
When the dough is baking the steam inflates the abundant egg proteins in big pockets. This happens in the first part of baking and the rest of the time is setting the proteins and drying the exterior. If your interior truly has as tight a crumb as bread, this would have happened at the beginning of baking and the 5 minutes at the end would not affect it.
Pâte à Choux is very easy to make. I wonder about your process.
Recipes always consist of:
- Combine and scald, or boil, milk, butter, sugar, and salt,
- Add flour all at once and stir until it forms a cohesive ball that pulls away from the sides of the bowl,
- beat in the eggs one at a time.
I would make sure that your milk mixture was properly scalded and that your flour was mixed in well enough before adding the eggs. The flour should have gluten activated and its starches gelatinized before you add the eggs.
If you haven't been already, you might try using bread flour and see if the problem is lessened.
Pictures about "My éclair (pâte à choux) was doughy"
Quick Answer about "My éclair (pâte à choux) was doughy"
Just add extra eggs until you get that right consistency. Chances are you may have cooked the dough too long and too much water evaporated, but it can easily be fixed by adding extra eggs. Just make sure to add a little at a time, rather than a whole egg at once.Why is my choux dense?
If too much egg is added or if it is added too quickly, the Choux's ability to rise when baked will be affected. Similarly, if not enough egg is incorporated, it won't puff, causing it to be dense inside.Why are my eclairs not cooked from inside?
This happens in the first part of baking and the rest of the time is setting the proteins and drying the exterior. If your interior truly has as tight a crumb as bread, this would have happened at the beginning of baking and the 5 minutes at the end would not affect it.Why is my choux pastry thick?
It wasn't cooked enough or we added too many eggs. The choux pastry is too thick: If the choux pastry doesn't fall from the wooden spoon, then it's too thick. Whisk an egg in a bowl and gradually in a thin stream start adding a small amount of the whisked egg into the mixture, while mixing with an electric mixer.How do you know when choux pastry is cooked?
Check for done-ness at 25 minutes (10 mins + 15 mins). NB These choux buns will be a DEEP golden brown when done \u2013 and crisp and hollow like a table tennis ball. DO NOT take them out too early, as the insides will still be wet. If you're not sure, remove just ONE bun and cut it open and see for yourself.i am unique
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Nick Collins, RODNAE Productions, Laker, RODNAE Productions