Is there any point in considering sous vide for unskilled newbie cook?

I'm a fan of sous vide, and I'm pretty sure it wouldn't make a good present.

Sous vide is mainly a technique for improving quality, not speeding up already fast dishes. It can also help move the busy times around (e.g., so you're not so busy when all your guests arrive, useful at a restaurant or if you host parties).

First, it's slow. A steak on a grill, you start that something like half an hour before you're going to eat, and that includes starting the charcoal. Less time for gas. A quick sous vide steak would probably be around an hour twenty before. Most of that time is just a bag sitting in the water bath, you don't even need to be home watching it. But it'd be a very late dinner after getting home from work.

The basic workflow is first prep and sometimes brown ingredients, second get them in a bag, third they sit in the water bath for a long time (hours, typically), fourth pull from water bath, fifth finish (brown again, garnish with sauces, season, etc.).

And honestly, it's fiddly. At least with reasonably priced equipment. You can (and I often do) use ziploc freezer bags, but getting enough air out so they don't float takes practice (and good clips to attach them to a rack). Non-chamber vacuum sealers are often a pain, as they try to suck any liquids into the seal area (often resulting in a failed aeal).

I think most sous vide cookbooks, etc. are also intended for non-novice cooks.

But if you get it right, it makes an amazing steak!

For soups and stews, I'd suggest a slow cooker (Crock Pot). Prep in the morning, cook all day while at work, ready when you get home. Or, going the opposite direction, a pressure cooker. Personally I've only used stovetop ones, but I hear the electric ones are really easy to use, though slightly less capable than stovetop.

I'd say it's not so much about the skill of the presentee, but more about whether they enjoy cooking and expanding their foodie knowledge. As has been said, sous vide as such is not particularly complicated - actually, it's probably simpler in some ways: For example, it's e.g. pretty foolproof for many dishes. Furthermore, it could be especially suitable for people with little time: Many items are sous-vided for some time around 24 hours, and do not need any supervision in between, so they could be started one evening and finshed the next evening. This would be much easier than producing e.g. a roast that has to be braised for three hours. In that sense, sous vide is a very helpful technique for busy people.

However, there is some effort and planning involved, and so sous vide is primarily suitable for people who consider cooking (at least partially) as a hobby. So:

• If your friend is a newbie who does enjoy cooking, tries new recipes and techniques etc., then sous vide is a very good technique they should learn. They will become better cooks quickly, and tehy can start sou-videing stuff right away.
• If, on the other hand, they are happy with waht they can do in the kitchen and get reasonable meals out of it, then a sous vide is not the right thing - it would be juts a toy that sits on the shelf.

Judging from your description, your firend is more likely to be in the latter category, but you'll have to decide for yourself.

I think there is a lot of learning to be done with Sous vide. Preferred temperatures, preferred cooking times, flavourings, etc. I am an avid and experienced cook, and I have done a lot of research and experimenting to find my preferred options for SV-ing different proteins, cuts of meat, and so on. There is a lot of varying information out there, so it is really a matter of finding what suits your palate.

Having said that, I LOVE sous vide, and I get results with it that I have never been able to achieve any other way.

But if someone isn't already interested in trying new ways of cooking and new techniques, I think it would be one of those things that would sit in the back of a cupboard unused.

Maybe a slow cooker might be an option that is easier to use for someone that isn't a keen cook...just chuck some meat and veges in, and leave it!

Like you, I know only that sous vide is super trendy. But I think you have answered your own question when describing your friend's attitude and relationship to cooking in general.

Unless that person has expressed an interest in beginning to practice the sous vide cooking technique, it sounds to me like some other gift would be more appropriate.