Does frying in canola instead of shortening change the fry time?
I had a bunch of canola oil and didn't want to go out and buy some shortening for a new recipe I found for beignets. The recipe called for heating 3-inches of shortening up to 370F to fry them in so I did the same with canola.
The fry time was to be 3 minutes but the first few I tried were too doughy. The next few I did for 4 minutes and, again, too doughy. Even at 5 minutes the inside was too wet. They are to be served hot so letting them sit for long isn't really an option.
I kept a thermometer in the pot and maintained that 370F temp pretty well. Other than the doughy to wet inside, they puffed up nicely and had good flavor.
So is there something I'm not aware of?
Best Answer
The type of fat you use makes no difference in cooking time, as long as you use a fat with a smoke point above that you want to cook at. There's a related question on the site about fats for deep frying which talks about the properties of different fats. Canola is absolutely fine to use instead of crisco or some other shortening.
It sounds to me like you had the fat just where you needed to be, I think what went wrong is your dough. From what you describe it sounds like you may have had it too moist. Moisture is important in the dough as it's the conversion of water to steam that gives you the puff, but too much moisture means you will saturate it. Try a thicker dough.
Pictures about "Does frying in canola instead of shortening change the fry time?"
Quick Answer about "Does frying in canola instead of shortening change the fry time?"
The type of fat you use makes no difference in cooking time, as long as you use a fat with a smoke point above that you want to cook at.What is the difference between frying in shortening and frying in oil?
Foods fried in oils absorb more of the fat, which remains in liquid form and is perceived as oiliness or greasiness. Shortening, made by hydrogenating vegetable oil to make it act like a solid, saturated fat, is the frying fat of choice for the doughnut industry.Can you use canola for frying?
Canola oil is another oil with a high smoke point, making it suitable for shallow frying.Why is canola better for frying?
The oil with the lowest level of saturated fat happens to be canola oil, whose smoke point of 425 to 475 F makes it an excellent choice for deep frying.Can you mix canola oil and shortening for frying?
Mixing the OilsTo mix the oil, add the Crisco to the pan, turn the heat to low and let it melt. Once the Crisco has melted, you can determine how much liquid oil you need to make up the difference. Add one of the vegetable oils with a light flavor and high smoke point and turn up to your normal cooking temperature.Most Dangerous Cooking (Avoid these Completely) 2022
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Gary Barnes, Kelly L, Gary Barnes, Gary Barnes