Controlling variables in homemade yogurt
Making yogurt at home is a fairly straight-forward process. Heat milk to 180F (82C), cool that milk to at least 110F (43C), add live cultures, usually in the form of yogurt with said cultures, incubate, then chill.
There are several variables in the process, some of which are: The fat content of the milk (I typically use whole), how long to hold the milk during the initial heat step, how long it takes to cool the milk, the temperature of the incubation step, and the length of time for incubation, to name a few.
While length of time for incubation, and temperature at this stage, clearly contribute to sourness, I am trying to nail down the variable that contributes to a creamy texture. I'm not referring to breaking or clumping, as described in Why isn't my homemade yogurt smooth?. My yogurt comes out smooth.
My initial hypothesis is that holding the milk for a length of time at the initial 180F(82C) (rather than immediately removing from heat and/or chilling) has an impact on final texture. Any thoughts or experience that might inform my hypothesis?
Best Answer
I've been experimenting with goat milk yogurt - changing things up one variable at at time. I've been able to get a consistently creamy texture with 10 minutes at 195, one hour at 120, and then lowering to 86 and incubating until it reaches a pH of around 4.3. A lower pH or a higher incubation temperature result in a more tart (of course) but also more firmly set yogurt. At 4.3 I get something silky smooth.
Pictures about "Controlling variables in homemade yogurt"
What determines the thickness of yogurt?
The thickness of the yogurt results from the coagulated proteins determined by the fat content of the milk, the yogurt starter, and amount of milk solids (protein). Adding nonfat milk powder (milk solids) to cold milk before heating will result in a firmer yogurt.How do you thicken homemade yogurt?
TIPS TO THICKEN YOGURTHow do catalysts turn milk into yogurt?
To turn milk into yogurt, these bacteria ferment the milk, turning the lactose sugars in the milk into lactic acid. The lactic acid is what causes the milk, as it ferments, to thicken and taste tart.What makes homemade yogurt watery?
If you're making yogurt using an heirloom starter culture that requires activation, it's not uncommon for the activation batch to be somewhat liquidy and thin. This is perfectly normal, as the bacteria in the freeze-dried cultures are just starting to wake up and get active during the first batch.INSTANT POT: How To Make Thick \u0026 Creamy Yogurt
More answers regarding controlling variables in homemade yogurt
Answer 2
The initial heating stage takes a little time to denature the water soluble proteins in the milk.
The hotter your milk, the faster the process. At 180 it takes 30 minutes. At 190 it takes 15 or so. Heating the milk longer than this won't improve the texture. I don't believe the texture will change very much unless too much water is lost.
Heating for a shorter time than this will make the yogurt significantly more fragile and less creamy.
"The milk mixture is pasteurized at 185°F (85°C) for 30 minutes or at 203°F (95°C) for 10 minutes." http://www.milkfacts.info/Milk%20Processing/Yogurt%20Production.htm
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Alexander Mils, Ella Olsson, ROMAN ODINTSOV, Nicola Barts