Are American food colourings weaker than in other countries?

I was looking at baking a yet-to-be-determined-colour velvet cake, and happened upon a recipe for blue velvet cake: http://bakebakebake.livejournal.com/3342197.html

This calls for two tablespoons of food colouring! The food colouring I am most familiar with is stuff like McCormick's, which is generally measured by the drop. Generating an entire tablespoon of a single colour would probably require several packets' worth.

Am I misunderstanding something? Are the comparative strengths the same and you just need a heck of a lot of colouring to make a cake that dark? Or is the American stuff a lot weaker and I'd only need the 4-5 drops I would expect from a recipe?

baking coloring

Best Answer

The simple answer is: No.

First of all the recipe says 1 tablespoon of blue food coloring. This is pretty typical for a velvet cake. In fact it's actually less than I would expect. This is because the original color is dark brown from the cocoa powder. To cover that up and turn it into a different color requires a lot of food coloring.

If you take a look at these standard red velvet cakes, you will see that they ask for 1 ounce food coloring. And 1 fluid ounce is equivalent to 2 tablespoons.

Pictures about "Are American food colourings weaker than in other countries?"

Are American food colourings weaker than in other countries? - Tasty cake with flag on bunch of paper dollars

Are American food colourings weaker than in other countries? - Purple Grapes

Are American food colourings weaker than in other countries? - From above of bitten and whole festive chocolate cupcakes decorated with miniature american flags and placed on white table

Is American food poor quality?

Study finds Americans eat food of mostly poor nutritional quality - except at school. Whether eating out or buying food from the grocery store, Americans of all ages are, for the most part, eating poorly everywhere--except at school.

Why is American food so low quality?

American food is in a crisis, states economist Tyler Cowen. Many Europeans agree that American food has problems: massive portions, excess fat, high levels of sugar, or any combination of those.

Does Europe have higher food standards than the US?

The U.S. tends to take a more reactive approach towards regulating food and beverage ingredients, while Europe takes a more proactive approach. Only additives proven to be non-harmful are approved for use in Europe, while in the U.S. food additives are innocent until proven guilty.

Is food healthier in Europe than USA?

From personal preference and culture to federal regulations, it's clear European food is healthier and more nutritious, which results in better taste. If Americans want to reflect this healthier diet, they need to exercise savvy shopping and clever cooking.

Common American Foods That Are Banned In Other Countries

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: JESHOOTS.com, Karolina Grabowska, Luiz M. Santos, Karolina Grabowska