Why did this cake fail?

Why did this cake fail? - Free stock photo of contemporary, easter, elegant

I made this cake in a borrowed bundt pan (i.e., I'm not used to baking in it), which I greased with cooking spray. This was the result:

enter image description here

Not only did large sections stick to the pan and tear out upon removal, but there's that thick semi-burnt crust on the surface.

  • The tear-out suggests that the pan wasn't greased properly, but I typically get pretty good coverage with that spray.
  • The semi-burnt crust suggests that the oven was too hot, but, while I've never actually tested the oven, I've used it for years with no problems, so I'm pretty confident that it's accurate.

Does anyone have a thought as to what happened here?



Best Answer

Batters full of starches and sugars are always sticky, how you prevent it from sticking partly depends on the plan. Some pans have coatings which while called non-stick aren't, but do reduce sticking somewhat. On pans like these often buttering is sufficient, and 'normal' cake pan shapes allow you to loosen the sides by running a knife around the side, so even if they stick you can free the cake. Putting a piece of baking paper on the bottom of a flat bottomed pan is a sure-fire way of preventing issues.

When you have an odd shape like a bundt, paper won't work, and you can't afford anything sticking, so the best way to ensure it frees is to generously butter (not oil or spray) the pan and then flour it. You can also make cake release, which can be sprayed or brushed on, using equal volumes of flour, oil and shortening.




Pictures about "Why did this cake fail?"

Why did this cake fail? - White and Brown Bread on Black Surface
Why did this cake fail? - Free stock photo of adult, birthday, cake
Why did this cake fail? - White and Brown Cake With White Icing on Pink Table



What are the causes of failure in cake?

Top 10 Causes of Cake Failure:
  • Cake Falling: Too much shortening or sugar. ...
  • Undersized Cake: Too large a pan. ...
  • Moist, Sticky Crust: Too much sugar. ...
  • Thick, Heavy Crust: Over baking. ...
  • Peaks or Cracks on Top: Too hot an oven. ...
  • Soggy Layer or Streak at Bottom: Insufficient mixing. ...
  • Heavy, Compact Texture: Over mixing. ...
  • Dry Cake:


How do you fix a failed cake?

Glue it together with frosting Clearly a bottle of Elmer's won't do the trick when it comes to a broken cake. Instead, make frosting work double duty as an adhesive to hold the pieces of cake together. Buttercream and mascarpone are the best options.



The Funniest Cake Fails




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA, ROMAN ODINTSOV, Arina Krasnikova, Pavel Danilyuk