What could the dough of this cookie be made of?

What could the dough of this cookie be made of? - Person Using a Cookie Cutter

After repeatedly eating what I consider the most delicious cookie I have ever eaten, my wife soon became frustrated trying to replicate it. So I am reaching out to gather ideas. This is the cookie, from a pastry shop. The filling is some kind of soft nougat, but the mysterious part is the cookie itself.

Here are some thoughts:

  • We assume that ingredients include (shortbread): flour, butter, and sugar
  • We tried icing sugar but it became too sweet
  • We tried milk with unclear success (?)
  • We tried eggs (white, yolk) but the taste did not match and it became too soft
  • The surface is a bit sticky
  • The taste is sweet and salty, a bit toasted/burnt which makes it so special

Unfortunately, I was not able to take a picture of a full cookie, so here is it half-eaten, as I could not control myself.

What could the dough be made of?

enter image description here



Best Answer

This is quite a shot in the dark with the minimal information, but I will give it a try.

My best guess is that you already have all the ingredients you need: butter, sugar and flour. What you are missing is probably the ratio. The dark edge with the crisp texture and the nutty flavor is very likely sugar that has self-caramelized in melting butter (similar to the tuille somebody mentioned in comments). Also, the image shows that the cookie is "flowing" - it was not stamped out from a rolled short crust, for example, it was a ball which melted in the oven. And it melted enough that it became very thin, with the edges flowing out to become thinner than the center.

I would suggest that you don't continue trying random recipes, but find a recipe for a cookie of this kind and follow it. You are most likely to find these recipes as recipes for malleable cookies for making e.g. edible ice cream bowls. I don't have my books here, so I can't post the recipe I have (you can come tonight(CET) into chat, if you want) but you can just search for this type of recipe online. Even if you don't find the perfect match, it will probably be a better starting point than random trying.

If you insist on trying yourself though, or cannot find one of these recipes, I would suggest you modify a German shortbread ratio (3-2-1 flour-butter-sugar). Make sure you are using butter, not a margarine or other substitutes, these have different spreading behavior when melting. And then simply reduce the flour substantially, possibly also increase the sugar, and see where that takes you.




Pictures about "What could the dough of this cookie be made of?"

What could the dough of this cookie be made of? - Person Holding White Hexagonal Baking Mold
What could the dough of this cookie be made of? - Assorted Cookies
What could the dough of this cookie be made of? - From above of crop unrecognizable female opening oven and putting baking pan with uncooked cookies inside oven in kitchen



What type of cookie is made from dough?

A drop cookie is any cookie that's made by dropping spoonfuls of dough directly onto a baking sheet. This means lots of cookies can be drop cookies such as chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and more.

What are the 3 types of cookie dough?

Here are the 10 most popular kinds of cookie dough in 2018.
  • Chocolate Chip. The classic favorite, chocolate chip, will never go out of style. ...
  • Snickerdoodle. Cinnamon is the secret ingredient in Snickerdoodle cookies that has people raving. ...
  • Sugar Cookie. ...
  • Oatmeal/Oatmeal Raisin. ...
  • M&M. ...
  • Peanut Butter. ...
  • Cake Batter. ...
  • Naked.


  • What is cookie made of?

    A cookie is a baked or cooked snack or dessert that is typically small, flat and sweet. It usually contains flour, sugar, egg, and some type of oil, fat, or butter. It may include other ingredients such as raisins, oats, chocolate chips, nuts, etc.

    What is cookie dough used for?

    Cookie dough is very versatile Besides baking cookies with it, you can also add it as filling to cupcakes, cakes and other desserts to add some extra sweetness. Edible cookie dough also goes great with ice cream and as a topping on other sweet treats.



    Edible Cookie Dough Recipe




    Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

    Images: Nicole Michalou, JÉSHOOTS, JÉSHOOTS, SHVETS production