Recipes for cookie cutters vs drop cookies
Today I made a batch of sugar cookies using my new snowflake-shaped cookie cutters; when I pulled them out, they had puffed so much they became flower-shaped instead. What should I look for in a recipe to use cookie cutters on versus one that would be better for drop cookies or a sliced log? Specifically, I suppose I don't want them to rise much after cutting - do I want less leavening? Smaller flour to butter ratio? How much?
Best Answer
A couple of things will lead to less spreading:
Shortening instead of butter - butter contains up to 20% water. When it reaches 212F/100C, it turns to steam, expands, and causes things to rise/puff. Also, shortening, as a more processed/refined fat, has a more even melting point, which would cause it to spread less. If you want the flavor of butter, consider butter-flavored shortening. If you must use butter, use clarified butter instead, as it has most of the moisture removed.
Refrigerate the dough -- the fat will melt later, causing less spreading by the time the starches and proteins set.
Egg whites -- stiffens a dough.
White vs. brown sugar - brown sugar contains more moisture than refined white sugar.
Pictures about "Recipes for cookie cutters vs drop cookies"
Can you use cookie cutters on drop cookies?
The reason using a drop cookie recipe doesn't work for cookie cutters, even if you could cut them out (we'll talk about that in a second), is because when the dough goes into the oven, your perfect little Christmas tree cut out is going to basically look like it exploded and become one blob of nothing due to the ...What is the difference between cut out cookies and drop cookies?
Drop cookies are made by dropping the dough in balls on a baking sheet. Cut out cookies are made by rolling the dough thin and using cookie cutters. Drop cookies are typically thicker and have add ins while cut out cookies are thin and plain.What types of cookies can you use cookie cutters for?
Cookie Dough Recommendations for Cutouts- Several different variations of chocolate chip cookies. ...
- Cookie recipes that use pudding mix in the recipe (like some chocolate chip cookie recipes & this pistachio chocolate chip cookie recipe)
- Soft & chewy sugar cookies.
- Snickerdoodles.
- Different cake mix cookies.
- Oatmeal cookies.
Easy Cut Out Sugar Cookie Recipe | Wilton
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou