Is it okay for oil to smoke in stir-fry?
I've always been taught that when frying anything at all, it's of the utmost importance keep the oil below its smoke point. Once the oil starts smoking, I've heard, it's game over-- the oil is denatured and everything in it will have its flavor ruined. And, from limited experience pan frying and deep frying things (I'm still working on the basics), I've seen that this is true. Once the temperature climbs too high, the oil starts to stink and the food ends up tasting like rancid oil.
But, when I watch stir-fry video tutorials, there's almost always smoke. Not just a little bit, either-- it looks like they're thoroughly burning their oil. For example, here's Chef Hiroyuki Terada making chicken fried rice: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UzbRwICWODk (he adds the oil to his wok at 3:45). I have no doubt that Hiro knows how to make a delicious stir-fry, but would it be better if he didn't let the oil smoke? Is the high temperature more important than the integrity of the oil? Or, am I completely missing something, and the oil isn't being denatured at all?
Best Answer
Yes, there's smoke coming off the oil, but it's not heavy, black smoke.
If you're frying things, when I see that, it's a sign to either get the pan off the heat, or to get food into the pan to cool it down.
When you're stir-frying, you want very high heat, so you're often working right at the smoke point. Whereas, for sautéing, I always learned to put the food in when it shimmers, but before it starts to smoke.
So, should you let the oil smoke? Generally, no, but it's okay if you use it as an indicator for when to put in food if you're quick about it.
update: To answer the culinary questions in your comment :
- The oil does denature, but it's not all denaturing at once, just like when you boil water, it doesn't all evaporate at once. Or if you burn an item, the whole thing doesn't instantly turn to ash. It's not a boolean (yes/no) answer, it's a question of the degree to which it's denatured. Letting it smoke so you know when to put in the food isn't the same as if you let it sit there an smoke for 5 minutes because you don't have your food ready.
- Moist food will cool off the oil because the water will turn to steam, resulting in evaporative cooling. This process ends up sucking energy (heat) out of the oil in the process. Flipping the food repeatedly (as you would with a sauté and some people do with a stirfry) can also cool down the pan, as you have more heat transfering to the air (more surface exposed while it's being flipped), and you typically lift the pan off the burner so there isn't as much new heat entering the system.
Pictures about "Is it okay for oil to smoke in stir-fry?"
Quick Answer about "Is it okay for oil to smoke in stir-fry?"
If you stir fry using oil with a smoking point below 450F, not only will the food taste bad, it will also be a health hazard. But isn't it already a health risk to allow the oil to smoke? No, actually. It's allowing the oil to heat up until bluish smoke becomes visible that poses danger.Should oil be smoking when frying?
Smoking oil isn't always a problem: there are times when it's inevitable, such as when you're stir-frying in an extremely hot wok. Typically, however, smoking is a sign that your oil is breaking down.Should oil be smoked in a wok?
Generally, no, but it's okay if you use it as an indicator for when to put in food if you're quick about it. update: To answer the culinary questions in your comment : The oil does denature, but it's not all denaturing at once, just like when you boil water, it doesn't all evaporate at once.Why is my wok smoking?
The wok will start to change color as you hold it over the heat, and it'll probably start to smoke. That's all right \u2014 that's residual oils left from the manufacturing process. Heat all areas of the wok completely, turning and tilting it as you go, then set it aside to cool.How to avoid oil fumes during stir-fry. And not to set off the smoke detector!
More answers regarding is it okay for oil to smoke in stir-fry?
Answer 2
The concept here is Hot wok cold oil First you need to reduce the heat off the wok before add oil. Then, add 'heap' of oil and pour out what you dont need. If you add little, the oil will burnt.
if he would to drain all the oil from the wok, the oil will be all black because it has all burnt. If you cook with burnt oil everything else will stick to the wok, like the eggs that he added. And a very high chance you burnt what you cook.
You need oil with high smoke point. In this case I don't know what he use. But I recommend canola and vegetables oil.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Gagan Cambow, Loïc Manegarium, Aphiwat chuangchoem, Johannes Plenio