Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute?

Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute? - Tasty marmalade in glass jar with written title near bread loaf for breakfast on plate

The glass lid for my pyrex 10x10 baking dish broke. What can I substitute? Tin foil doesn't work -- nothing cooks! Ideas?

Thank you.



Best Answer

One "hack" to try is to put a larger glass baking dish on top (e.g. 9"x13" over an 8"x8"). It is heavy enough to make a moderately decent seal.




Pictures about "Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute?"

Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute? - Spice Bottles on Shelf
Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute? - Glass jar with transparent liquid placed on white table
Glass baking lid broke - what to substitute? - Three Mason Jars Inlined on White Surface



How to cover a baking dish without a lid?

If the pan you are using does not come with a suitable lid then you may need to use a layer, or even a double layer, of foil to cover the pan. In slow cooked recipes, such as stews and braises, the long cooking time means that the dish must be tightly covered so that the ingredients don't dry out.

What can I use as a casserole lid?

Foil. A double sheet of foil works well as a lid when you need a closer fit than a sheet pan or a frying pan would provide. It's a little more difficult to manipulate than a lid, but it traps heat and moisture just as effectively.

What happens when glass breaks in oven?

What Make Glass Shatter? When glass goes rapidly from something cold to hot (like a freezer to an oven) or vice versa, it can experience \u201cthermal shock.\u201d Different sections of a piece of bakeware can expand or contract differently and cause it to lose its structure, resulting in a shattering effect.

Do glass lids break?

Another characteristic of tempered glass is the possibility of "spontaneous or delayed breakage" where, over time, scractches on the lid, visible or invisible to the eye, will weaken the tempering of the glass, eventually causing the lid to explode or implode for no apparent reason.



Baking Tip #7 Glass vs. Metal Baking Dishes




More answers regarding glass baking lid broke - what to substitute?

Answer 2

I usually using a big plate for this (but make sure it can handle the heat or slowly heat it up) or as previously suggested use a bigger lid. Sometimes a flat baking form like for a quiche does work as a lid as well (a friend of mine even used a frying pan once). Just be creative and look for something that is heat resistant and large enough to cover the top.

Answer 3

I don't think there is something readymade which you can substitute. Other dishes, plates, etc. as suggested in other answers are somewhat usable, but tend to 1) not fit well, and 2) not have handles. The result is that, when you are taking the hot pan out of the oven, you risk a hot porcelain plate sliding and landing on the floor breaking, or on your lap and burning you. Whether you first try lifting the "cover" with mitt-clad hands, or getting the whole package out of the oven, it's a tricky situation.

Unless you happen to have a second dish with a very convenient shape which holds well to your pan, there is no low-effort solution that would be worth it long-term. If you don't want to buy a lid, you can try creating one yourself, but that would require advanced skills in pottery, metalworking or something else appropriate to the chosen material, and cost you more time (and possibly more money in material) than a new lid.

The second question is, we don't know what you are cooking. "Tin foil doesn't work - nothing bakes" sounds like you may have a situation where you need a high radiation (Toaster oven? Something like a lasagna which needs a crispy crust?) and then nothing but glass will help if you are baking with a lid 100% of the time. If this is the case, try baking longer with a less-penetrable lid on and then doing the last 10-15 min without a lid, possibly on a "grilling" setting.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Lisa, Pixabay, Jill Burrow, Ella Olsson