Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings?

Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings? - Top view of delicious sliced oranges arranged near each other as minimalist background of organic nutrition

With a mother-in-law who hails from the North of England I am well aware that when I make Yorkshire puddings my method is scrutinized. Luckily I have been assured by the master of such delights that my method is correct. First put in the flour, then the egg then the milk - any other way (as in putting the milk before the egg) just does not work! OK, it may sound silly, but I would never consider doing it any other way.

Can other methods work, or is this the only one which will give good results?



Best Answer

People for decades have been convinced that there's one "right" way to make Yorkshire Puddings. The reality is that most if not all of these "tricks" are either unnecessary or outright hurt the outcome.

Kenji over at Serious Eats went a bit bonkers and tried out just about all of the different methods and has summarized it in an article which is paired with his "best Yorkshire puddings" recipe.

While testing the order of adding milk and eggs to flour actually wasn't one of the things he does, the first step of his recipe is to simply mix together the flour, eggs, and milk (plus a tablespoon of water and some salt) - all simultaneously.

  • Combine eggs, flour, milk, water, and salt in a medium bowl and whisk until a smooth batter is formed. Let batter rest at room temperature for at least 30 minutes. Alternatively, for best results, transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate batter overnight or for up to 3 days. Remove from refrigerator while you preheat the oven.

If you're really interested in Yorkies, I strongly suggest you read his article and consider trying the recipe out for yourself. If you want a summary, I've created a shorter version of it in an answer on this previous question.




Pictures about "Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings?"

Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings? - Delicious dessert with berries on coaster
Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings? - Asian island food on plate placed on table with welcome page of  cafe menu
Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings? - Person Wearing White Gloves Holding a Dough



Quick Answer about "Does ingredient order matter when making Yorkshire Puddings?"

First put in the flour, then the egg then the milk - any other way (as in putting the milk before the egg) just does not work!

What ingredient makes Yorkshire puddings rise?

Forget about cold batter: letting it rest at room temperature helps it rise taller as it bakes. A combination of milk and water gives the Yorkshire puddings extra rise and crispness.

What is the secret to making Yorkshire puddings?

Top tips for making Yorkshire puddings
  • Let your batter rest. ...
  • Use an egg white for extra height. ...
  • Don't take them out until they're ready. ...
  • Give them plenty of of space in the oven. ...
  • Use a jug for control. ...
  • Utilise your freezer. ...
  • Give them a quick blast on a high heat.


  • What makes Yorkshire puddings not rise?

    Why don't my Yorkshire puddings rise? The most common culprit is not enough heat. To ensure the water in the batter turns into steam, the fat or oil in the pudding cup must be very hot. This means the oven must be hot enough and the fat must be given time to heat until it is almost smoking.

    Why are my Yorkshire puddings rubbery?

    You leave the batter to rest to allow the gluten in the flour to relax, this makes the batter tender. If you don't allow the batter to relax the yorkshire pudding will be slightly tough and rubbery.



    Chef Sarge says the secret to cooking proper Yorkshire puddings is air and patience




    Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

    Images: Karolina Grabowska, Any Lane, ROMAN ODINTSOV, Mikhail Nilov