Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate]

Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate] - Young discontented African American female with folded arms against male partner at kitchen table during quarrel

I would like to know what are the causes for a chiffon cake to have a caved in centre.

After baking, the cake turns out with a nice dome. The cake is overturned immediately to cool. But after about 15 minutes of cooling, the centre of the cake which was previously a dome became caved in (not too deeply caved in, maybe just about 2cm from the level of the cake height.)

So the result after the cake is cooled, the top of the cake (which was previously the bottom) is light and fluffy and the bottom of the cake (which was previously the top) is dense.

The sides and bottom of the cake are evenly browned. The sides do not shrink as much as the centre.

The cake is baked at 160C-Fan for 45min for a 5-egg recipe. I use cake flour and a very small amount of baking powder.



Best Answer

Welcome to the site @Jules. Your temperature is right and you did get rise, it sounds to me like your cake was underbaked, which is why it collapsed. When you bake a cake (or any batter) you get rise from the creation of steam, expansion of air due to heat, and leavening agents creating gas from the reaction between an acid and a base. This expansion stretches the batter, which needs to crystallize in order to retain its shape. If you don't bake it long enough the structure of the cake won't hold, and when it cools it snaps back and becomes very dense.

The times given on a recipe are guidelines, you get different baking times because of differences in ovens, equipment, even the temperature and humidity of your kitchen. Because of this you have to bake to the result you want. The method I use for determining when a chiffon cake is done is to listen rather than touch. A chiffon cake pops a lot, it's done when the popping slows down to less than one pop per second. Firstly, don't open the oven until at least 10 minutes after the cake stops rising, you don't want to disturb it. At that point you'll probably hear lots of popping. I give 5 minutes between pop checks until I hear the popping noticeably lessen, then I check every 2 minutes. You can also use the touch test, you want the cake to spring back, but for me the pop test works every time.




Pictures about "Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate]"

Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate] - Clear Drinking Glass Filled With Liquid
Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate] - Slices of Bread On White Ceramic Plate
Chiffon Cake Problem [duplicate] - Sliced Chocolate Cake on White Ceramic Plate Beside Stainless Steel Spoon



What went wrong with my chiffon cake?

Beat egg whites correctly: Under-beating egg whites will cause the cake structure to collapse, while over-beating can cause the mixture to break down when you fold it into the batter, creating a heavy batter. Therefore, always keep an eye out for the egg whites as they thicken.

Why is my chiffon cake dense in the middle?

If you deflate the egg whites too much (over fold) then the cake will be dry and dense instead of fluffy. I recommend using a whisk to fold in the dry ingredients instead of a spatula. That way, the dry ingredients are incorporated without the egg whites deflating as much.

Why is my chiffon cake not spongy?

There are a few possible reasons for this. This may be caused by the improper whisking of the egg whites. The egg whites might be under-whisked or over-whisked so the cake does not rise to its optimum height. The meringue might not have been folded into the batter in the correct manner.

Why do chiffon cakes deflate in the oven?

Chiffon cake can shrink and deflate for several reasons. First, the pan had a non-stick coating or if it was greased. The best pan to use for a voluminous cake is an aluminum, un-greased chiffon pan without a non-stick coating. Second, the cake can shrink and deflate if not completely cooled immediately after baking.



Banana Chiffon Cake / 3 Most Common Mistakes When Baking Chiffon Cake




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Alex Green, Cats Coming, Mumma Oyens, Karolina Grabowska